When an LP is pressed using a digital master recording as the source, does that LP still have an analog advantage?
It sure seems that way. What makes it hard to say for certain is the problem of how to compare. Because what you're asking really boils down to which is better the LP or the CD. And while we all know the answer, the CD guys can't handle the truth, and will deny to the point of death, till you pry the remote from their cold dead hand.