Looking for a phono stage with pleasing coloration


I have recently completely overhauled my analog front end. I have gone from a Marantz TTS TT-15S1 with a Clearaudio Charisma to a Rega Planar 8 with a Soundsmith Paua II cartridge. There have been definite improvements; improvements in dynamics, resolution, and spatial separation.  Phono stage is currently a Tavish Adagio running into a Prima Luna Evo 300 preamp and Parasound JC 5 amp; speakers are Monitor Audio PL 100 II. I’m overall pleased with the system but I find it a little too modern sounding; instrument separation, and mid and low bass are a tad too tight and disciplined. While the Paua generally outclasses the Charisma; I preferred the tonality of the Charisma. Maybe it’s because the Charisma has a wooden body but it has more of a warmth and vintage coloration to its tonality that I like.


I would like to make change to Phono stage to address these issues, so looking for recommendations on a phono stage that has a bit more of a vintage coloration, body, warmth, slightly looser bass and low noise floor and retains good top end extension. I currently have the PS Audio Stellar phono on order for a home trial but every review I have read has praised it for its neutrality but what I really want is added coloration that I find pleasing.  I guess I can try tube rolling the Adagio but I don’t want to go down the rabbit hole of trying to find low microphonic NOS tubes. Finally I want to stay under $3K and I’m open to vintage phono preamps (but I don’t want to sacrifice dynamics and sound stage).


Ag insider logo xs@2xarize84

Showing 7 responses by arize84

Dealer came to my house and professionally installed Soundsmith; he also used shims to adjust VTA. I have always run cartridge at 400 ohms (and going up to 500 doesn't make much of a difference). I think the setup and installation is well done. I'm also already running NOS tubes (GE 12x7 and Siemens 12au7). I used to find tube rolling fun but I'm a bit over it now; there's just too much variability with tubes.
The Decware looks beautiful but the gain is too low. The gain on the Adagio is 64db but I wish it was a little higher. I like to run my poweramp slightly attenuated and drive more of the gain from my preamp (for whatever reason I find my system sounds better that way); preamp only has about 10db of gain so I'm already running it pretty hard hard. I know I'm going to sound picky but gear looks also matter to me and I just don't dig the industrial aesthetic of Audio Research gear. I also would like readily accessible controls on my phono stage (so not a fan of opening cases to tool around with dip switches). Price point wise, I could push myself to $4K for the right product. Thanks. 
I missed your comment regarding SUT for the Decware. I will look into this. Thanks.
@millercarbon nailed what I'm looking for by describing warm woody tone. My research is that most current audiophile phono stages are generally voiced to be neutral; I'm looking for a brand/model that is not shy of creating a noticeable house sound.
Gotta agree the 834P isn't cheap even used. For now, I'm going to wait on the PS Audio, maybe it will get me what I'm looking for if it at least gives me a fuller body to the sound. Other options are JC3+ and Gold Note but both these are described as very neutral. 
The adagio is very good and I can live with it but I just want some more body to the sound; for example my schiit yggdrasil definitely sounds fuller than my analog front end. Also honestly while the adagio looks OK, it still has that DIY look that you get from a lot of smaller manufacturers. The PS Audio should be here tomorrow, will see if that outclasses the adagio.

The new cartridge is way too expensive for me to even think of replacing it, and it also performs very well (it's just a tad leaner than my old cartridge). I went with the soundsmith because of their rebuild guarantee (I have had bad luck with not damaging my cartridges so this is important to me). 

I know I'm being picky but I'm very close to getting my system to a state where I'm completely satisfied with the sound and finally getting off the upgrade train for a while. 
@dover The PS Audio came and I have been listening to it for a few hours. From out of the box it was better than the Adagio.
  • It has a more muscular presentation and I'm getting more punch out of the cartridge
  • Using higher loading options(750 ohms); I got real benefits in the higher frequencies and upper mid range
  • What surprised me the most was in the increase in sound stage depth (both front and back).
  • It is also much quieter than the adagio
  • Finally build quality is really nice and very aesthetically pleasing

I also forgot to mention that I have only had the Paua for 2 weeks and I guess it is still breaking in; it now sounds a touch more lush than a couple of days ago.