Looking for a high-quality 2-way speaker


Has anyone ever compared: Rockport Alya, YG Acoustics Carmel, Magico S1 / Q 1 and Raidho C 1.1 / D 1 ?

Trying to help a friend building a "small scale" but very high quality and resolving system. Gear in use is Ayre AX-5 + Ayre DX-5. Everything wired with Cardas Clear.

Thanks for any useful help.
frankpiet

Showing 1 response by bhobba

I personally haven't compared them, but know someone who has.

The Rockport's were the winner - highly musical and realistic - the Magico was dry, analytical and brittle - and the YG was similarly analytical. The Raidho was was better, but still didn't have the realism and musicality of the Rockports.

Like another poster mentioned I would, in the price range of the speakers you are looking at, consider the Rockport Mira and arrange an immediate audition.

However if you wanted to take a bit of a punt to save a heap of money, the same person that has heard all those speakers (he is a real high end nut who goes to all the shows all the time and has heard everything under the sun - he got the Rockport's himself) was very impressed with my speakers - the ML2 Limited made by a guy down the road from where I live - Mike Lenehan at Lenehan Audio.

Made from MD3, lined internally with 1/4 inch copper, uses 10 gauge hand wound inductors, and Duelund Cast capacitors.

He judges them to be the equal of any speaker has heard - but at a lot less - about $15K. The problem is the chances of you being able to hear them is zero unless you live in Australia - which is why it will be a big punt.

Thanks
Bill