Listening to music matters Freddie Hubbard thought my woof was going to blow?

Lewm has it right. You are probably feeding back at low frequencies. Either your turntable is poorly isolated or you have a cartridge tonearm miss match. You said it happens with all turntable? What turntables, tonearms and cartridges? What is are the turntables on? If you have a cabinet that is vibrating it can pass this on to the turntables

The reissues are not cutting the bass. Many companies EQ the bass. Some companies like Mobile Fidelity in the old days boosted bass to make things more impressive.