Linear tracking turntables, whatever happened?


Curious as to the demise and downfall of the seemingly short lived linear tracking TT.
Just from a geometry point of view I would have thought a linear arm should be superior to one with a fixed pivot that sweeps through an arc.
Obviously there is much more to it than that, sort of the reason for this thread.
I am genuinely interested in trying one out for myself as well.
uberwaltz

Showing 4 responses by dgarretson

Thanks for the plug, Lew and Raul. Regarding Trans-Fi, I haven't kept up with Vic's latest innovations, but am all in on its excellent performance independent of price.  As a DIYer, I eventually migrated from the stock alum sled/cradle with knife bearings, to a customized assembly with point bearings and a lightened sled with a thin, reinforced carbon fiber shell around a foam core. The goal was to decrease horizontal mass, which in the stock setup is low relative to most linear tonearms but high relative to a pivot arm. To take things further, a friend with a medical instruments business fabricated a wand-less vertical bearing for the sled that accepts a standard detachable headshell.  This idea is versatile in terms accommodating interchangeable cartridges, but lightweight for low-compliance cartridges.  My overall experience is that Trans-Fi is at the intersection of commercial and DIY-- a fine and economical solution for anyone curious about linear tonearms.            

@ct0517 

Its DIY heritage begins with the original design by Poul Ladegaard. IIRC, he envisioned this as a linear tonearm that could be built at a kitchen table using basic tools and standard parts from a hardware store.  Vic at Trans-Fi turned that into a commercial offer, with a professional fit and finish and a steady stream of running improvements.  It's humble origin should in no way suggest that the design is unsophisticated. 

For the purchaser, the DIY part is principally the tank, pump, and airline.  This is no big deal, as all one needs is a low-pressure aquarium pump(mine is a Rena 400), a gallon plastic petrol can as a smoothing tank, silicone tubing, and brass nipple fittings from Home Depot.  The low operating pressure has design advantages, and avoids the complexity of the high pressure pumps associated with captured air bearings(e.g. extraction of moisture and compressor noise.)

Vic includes a Delrin tower on which to mount the arm base to a turntable plinth.  He builds each tower to the dimensions of platter height and armboard of the customer's TT. Alternatively, the customer can fabricate a tower with better metal materials such as brass or stainless steel.  I made a custom brass turntable base that drops into the stock collet of a Kenwood L-07D.  This preserves the VTA adjustment of the original Kenwood tonearm.      

Set-up is straight-forward, but it is critical to align the air manifold such that the stylus tracks a perfectly straight line from the perimeter of the LP to the center of the record spindle.  For a template, I took a 12" strobe disk and scribed a radius from the center of the spindle hole.  Once the manifold is painstakingly aligned, you wouldn't want to ruin that by pivoting it to change records.  The cue bar raises the wand enough to allow careful sliding of the LP in from the side.  This is only a hassle if the turntable has a really tall spindle.

One must carefully dress the flying tonearm wires through the supplied gantry to avoid torqueing the wand as the sled travels across the air manifold.  This takes practice, particularly with high compliance cartridges. 

One area ripe for DIY improvements is adding mass to the front of the flat wand in order to optimize vertical effective mass across a wide range of cartridge compliances.  I found it useful to machine a kit of small brass weights that can be dropped into the large holes in the wand between the cartridge mount and the vertical pivot bearing.

It's a neat high-performance arm.  IMO, it's only shortcoming is that it doesn't leave enough room to mount additional pivot arms to the TT.       

Sh*te, I need a proof-reader or new eyeglasses. It’s its when it's not it’s.
The tip of the long cue bar is  only point of potentially destructive contact with a carelessly handled LP.  I added a small rubber nipple to the tip to address that.