Lector CDP 7 Mk I, II or III ?


I plan to part with my second system Ayre gear to refinance a purchase for the main system and am considering to retain only the Yamamoto headphones with another good cdp. And so I came accross Lector, unknown on the local market and thus even more interesting.

Now, I did a search on Agon and found several people specifically advising the CDP 7 Mk I, clearly prefering it over the later versions.

Is the original Lector CDP 7 sonically better? Any specific reason for that?

Thanks in advance
Karel
karelfd

Showing 2 responses by mitch2

I have owned the CDP 7TL MkII and two MkIII's, either of which should sound better than the MkI. Lector made improvements from the MkI to the MkII in the power supply, chassis damping, and top drawer slider. The only difference from MkII to MkIII was changing the DAC board to accomodate the BB PCM-1704 24-bit chipset instead of the PCM-63 20-bit chipset. I have been told by two people who should have pretty good ears that they believe the MkII sounds better than the MkIII. I have been told by more people that the MkIII sounds better. HP from TAS implied the MkIII sounded better to him. My ears tell me they both sound great, and not so different from each other. The MkII projects a "creamier" slightly richer, fuller sound. The MkIII has better resolution and also falls on the rich, full side of the sonic scale compared to many others, but slightly less so compared to the MkII. I believe the bass is tighter with the MkIII, and also just as deep and powerful. The difference in sound is due to the two different DAC's used. I find the August 2007 Soundstage! review of the MkIII pretty much describes the sound. I kept the MkIII. It may not be the "best" but it is highly musical and highly enjoyable in the under $5K (used) price range. I preferred the sound of the MkIII Lector over the Blue Note Stibbert in a side-by-side comparison in my system, and I kept the Lector. The new price in the US is $5365, and there is now one for sale here for $2,100. I have no idea why it has been listed for 19 days without being sold.
That was a strong statement, and my point was simply that IMO the MkIII for $2,100 is a great deal. I have been thinking about trying other players, but dispite months of looking at options, every time I listen to my system with the Lector I think to myself, "can it really sound much better than this?" Even considering the current market conditions, as Reb1208 points out, anything I have strongly considered as a potential replacement has been in the vicinity of $4K used, or above. While I have had no problems whatsoever with any of the 3 Lectors I have owned, my other self-imposed criteria for a new player is that it be made in the USA, or at least have easily obtainable service in the USA, like Esoteric or Meridian. Of course, Tgyeti is correct about the zero feedback liability. I sometimes offer those sellers the option of COD.