KEF Blade or Giya Kaya 90/G4?


Has anyone heard the new Giya Kaya or the other two speakers mentioned?  They are competitively priced.  I sense they offer much of the same sound parameters, open, uncolored sound with a large soundstage.  Hopefully, they also offer dense, full-bodied musically interesting mids and quick/deep bass.  Are they close to SOTA (the Giya 4 is supposed to be a smaller sounding version of the Giya 1 per critics) other than in dynamics?  Can they be successfully driven by Class A/B tube amps of 70 to 125 watts?  Does the vonSchweikert VR55 Aktive offer more at double the price?  
fleschler

Showing 2 responses by audiotroy

Gentleman, we had the Vivid line and the Kef Blades and Reference at the same time in the same showroom.

Our take was the Kef line was similar sounding for less money then the Vivids.

We too heard the big Giyas and at $70-95k they were more dynamic with even greater bass punch then the Blades, however, a  pair of Blades with a pair of good subwoofers still would come out at half the price of the Giyas.

 A well setup pair of Blades is one of the very few $30k speakers that can be compared to $70-100k models from most of the industry.

We had the Oval B1 and V1.5 in our showroom and the B1 were superb, clarity, soundstaging, but in most respects were not better than the less expensive Kef Reference line. 

We ultimately gave up the Vivid line as they didn't really outperfom, the Kef's and both lines sounded similar with similar design attributes with both sporting very high tech aluminium drivers.

The Ref 3 or Ref 1 when setup correctly do sound similar to the Blades if the Blade 2 are still too big for your office.

Ysantabarbara, if you are looking for a fantastic smaller speaker listen to the new Quad Z series unbelievable performance for the money. The Z3 are tiny floorstanders, with one of the best sounding ribbon's that isn't sterile sounding or hyper detailed. 

Dave and Troy
Audio Doctor NJ


Yyssantabarbera, you will be so happy with the Blade 2. They are extraordinary loudspeakers.

As we mentioned before we had both lines the Blades sound more like the mega dollar speakers so we at one time were contemplating the Vivid G1 for our reference room but ruled them out due to the similarities in design between the two lines, with the Blades offering sound in the same calibre for half the price of the big Giyas, other than more extreme bass response, we ruled out the Giyas because the performance of the Blades was that good.

In terms of design and technology these are both tour de force loudspeakers, we feell that the Blades are better than the Vivids for less money the Blade 2 compares to the Giya G3 which is a $40k loudspeaker. The other issue with the Vivids sound is that they are even more detailed then the Blades which makes them a bit more sensitive to any brightness in a system.

The Blades are a perfect balance between resolution, sound staging, bass tightnss and punch.

Dave and Troy
Audio Doctor NJ