Jazz for aficionados


Jazz for aficionados

I'm going to review records in my collection, and you'll be able to decide if they're worthy of your collection. These records are what I consider "must haves" for any jazz aficionado, and would be found in their collections. I wont review any record that's not on CD, nor will I review any record if the CD is markedly inferior. Fortunately, I only found 1 case where the CD was markedly inferior to the record.

Our first album is "Moanin" by Art Blakey and The Jazz Messengers. We have Lee Morgan , trumpet; Benney Golson, tenor sax; Bobby Timmons, piano; Jymie merrit, bass; Art Blakey, drums.

The title tune "Moanin" is by Bobby Timmons, it conveys the emotion of the title like no other tune I've ever heard, even better than any words could ever convey. This music pictures a person whose down to his last nickel, and all he can do is "moan".

"Along Came Betty" is a tune by Benny Golson, it reminds me of a Betty I once knew. She was gorgeous with a jazzy personality, and she moved smooth and easy, just like this tune. Somebody find me a time machine! Maybe you knew a Betty.

While the rest of the music is just fine, those are my favorite tunes. Why don't you share your, "must have" jazz albums with us.

Enjoy the music.
orpheus10

Showing 50 responses by mahgister

Do you mean there is a difference in style when Michael Brecker play alone and when he play with his brother ?

 

I stumble on a "fusion" song i did not like much instead of jazz did you mean this ?

@mahgister 

I can listen to Michael Brecker all day long, and have. 
Having said that, I haven’t been able to get through a Becker Brothers album.

Maybe it’s just me?

Thanks a lot @frogman

I appreciate very much your musical erudition and necessary context knowledge...

It help us a lot...

Wow almost 900 albums...many where is a side musician but...

I spot  already only 32 in my research but all as main player ...

 

On the thirty two albums of Zorn it seems i cannot love more than 4 or 5 ...

The rest may be interesting but not enough for me to keep them in my love list...

The Album with Jamie Saft throw me toward him , and i discovered few albums of Saft as true gems... ( 6 albums)

I prefer classical jazz, sometimes i venture out of it but it is way more difficult for me to fall in love then ...

Zorn is really interesting... But interesting is not falling in love...

After the 6 albums of Saft i love , i now explore Brecker who really is a sax master ... Evident at first listening ... I will not fall in love with many Brecker albums in fusion or piop for sure... But his jazz albums will probably hit me at the heart it seems already with 2 listenings...

 

So I just got 6 John Zorn CD’s from the library. I tried to listen to them. Really I did! I guess I just don’t like that kind of jazz.

Oh well.

 

One thing appear to me and i just begun to listen to Brecker... His sax mastery musical control is good to the point of being embarassing or shaming for others .... I never hear so much surprizing variations with so much fluidity from any other sax player i listened too... Thanks frogman...

This does not means i cannot appreciate other musical style gesture of Igor Buttman or Wayne Shorter or Sonny Rollins etc...Musical gesture style is not linearly related to virtuoso control levels , it is constrained by them for sure, but music has a life of its own ...It is the reason why there is no absolutely better musician over all of them in jazz ... Too much possible expressive gestures repertory learned in so many musicians different body and personal story ....

There is also another point, nevermind the genius of any musician, the way his sideman work with him and underline his phrasing and sustain it and were inspired in their own playing make an album session great... It is evident with Miles Davis "kind of blue" which is not the best jazz album ever, there is no best ever, but in this album the SYNERGY between the players parts is astoundingly good...

Then it is the same conditions for any musician in jazz so great it is, he will need to play and inspire others...

Listen to my favorite Pat Martino album... "Formidable"... Here too the synergy is so much good that for me it is equal to "kind of blue"... Martino drive the other players to their best as Miles did ...By the way as " kind of blue" " formidable" album are not necessarily the best albums to decipher the specific  artistry and virtuosity of Miles or Martino but it is great album to look for and understand why and how they inspire other musicians to play at their top... The reason is simple : the geniuses as  Miles and Martino serve the other musicians and dont use them as replaceable  servant  but inspire them to go at their maximum level ... We feel it ...

 

Pat Martino and Michael Brecker had something in common in their own personal world..

I dont know how to say it or describe it... They play going on  with their own effortless FLUID  "pulse" leading in their wake the others musicians but without letting them aside or down... A feat some other geniuses playing more lonely lost in their world   did not do so well ...

Thats my impression...I discovered these 2 musicians i did not know with frogman recommendation... They are insanely good technically and musical...

 

 
 

 

 

This Michael Brecker album will make your candle supper at the dessert moment with a digestive liquor an amazing hour...

It is not the most original Brecker album probably, just classic jazz, but this musician finger/brain gestures flow as calming water on stressed feet...Brecker play more effortlessly than any other sax player i ever listened to, this is why HE NEVER DID TOO MUCH FOR MAKING AN IMPRESSION as many others do but he manage to stay creative and surprizing in his phrases without overdoing anything ...

Charlie Haden play with Brecker : american dreams...

Trumpet is no more my favorite Jazz instrument with piano... Sax enter my heart not only my brain or body now... Brecker is without rival exactly as frogman said it was... It is unbelievable if we dont listen to him because there is very great sax players for me already...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1k1dKriNws&list=PLvxWibFr0wiIAsj0hIMVXe51d_PqcmOZ6

 

I am torn between American dreams and "cityscapes" With Ogerman...😊

Absolute mastery of Brecker here...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p2m7_06jbXo&list=PL0hWpfLjtwxRrrhkMSbsZUEyrXwDz9HRd

We must buy the two albums...listen on youtube before doing so, especially cityscape which is not jazz style i will buy usually but Brecker sound divine here...

Thanks for the link frogman

 

I will add this as complement..

Michael Brecker: A Quiet Genius of Immense Importance

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bUFdzxcZhwg

and also this :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U6UsTFQMCPA

 

Thanks for the reference ...

I will order them too..

Re; Michael Brecker Just listened to his Pilgrimage album. It truly is a masterpiece.

I just ordered this and I cant wait to "dive in"

Ode to a Tenor Titan: The Life and Times and Music of Michael Brecker: Milkowski, Bill: 9781493053766: Amazon.com: Books

Exploring the Grolnick playings with Brecker i discovered Bob Mintzer another sax master playing with Brecker at least in one album ...Mintzer cannot rival brecker for sure, i did not heard someone who can , but he recorded many big band album...

What frogman think about him and his duet with Brecker ?

Too much good music to discover the same week for me....

it is way better to buy 10,000 bucks of music than a new dac.... especially if the one you own is already good as in my case... My two cents for a lost audiophile in the jazz thread.. ...

😊

Thanks frogman...

I begun to appreciate big band more this year... I will explore Mintzer...

Sound good to me and i am not a fan of big band save few exceptions... Thanks acman3..

I will investigate Mintzer band... After my inspection of the 900 albums of Brecker ...or before ... 😊

 

 

Thanks... I will go for it , after my Brecker disease ... 😊

I am stunned by Brecker...

@mahgister 

Spectrum is a good Mintzer album to start with.

Enjoy

"Spectrum" album seems very good to me...Thanks ...

More easy listening than the magic Brecker...I love Brecker .... I will like Mintzer it seems ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhKcML1Lpsc&list=OLAK5uy_mZB0UKS1f3KHax1t6v_9DurQPc9l8TJ90

i cannot listen Brecker albums when reading on the net , but i can listen relaxing big band this way... i listen music 6 hours each day.... 😁

i listen half of the time more attentively known favorites, the other half is devoted to new one in a more relaxed ways...

2,160 hours  in one year..

1080 hours for new albums... it takes roughly 1000 new albums a year for my novelties appetite and explorations...

Guess why i am not interesting by most useless gear upgrades ?

Guess why i came in this thread ?

😊

Dont be envious!

I exagerated the numbers as i wish them to be ... 😉

And anyway listen to frogman advices, he is a musician and he knows what he talk about ...

Me i just begun to understand jazz a bit...

i am retired and i had anything else to do...😁

 

@mahgister

I’m envious -- if I find one unfamiliar recording per month to enjoy, I’m consider myself lucky!

Can we clone your ears and transplant them onto my head? ;o)

 

Amazing good jazz :

"The truth" with Elvin Jones and Michael Brecker and Eubanks on trombone ,Darren Barrett trumpet and another sax with Brecker...

 

A sax god exactly as frogman said...

It is not a Brecker album mostly  even if he plays a part but the album is more than just interesting... So.... I am doubly amazed by Brecker and  this Jones album...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XxC7EhPnsuo&list=PLaw8u3Tc5UT6oi_-M6FiuHvmIAEz-u_th

 

 

 

I am happy if i repaid you for your enlightened recommendations that impacted me a lot , among others Pat Martino and Micharl Brecker... Sometimes it takes an explanation to understand why we must listen a musician in particular... You are able to do so  because of your musician experience to explain why we must hear someone twice more than once ... It help us all... Thanks ...

Fabulous! Can’t thank you enough, mahgister, as I was not aware of this recording.

I already had many albums of Desmond with Hall and it is amazing indeed .... I love him because it remind me of the human singing voice and stay always minimalistic to be such as a speaking or singing voice and sound nothing as the Brecker super human mastery of the instrument....It remind me of the complete different way Chet Baker sing or speak only most of the times with absolute minimalistic voicing  versus Miles masterful exploratory playing ...

When asked how he got that distinctive sound, Paul Desmond replied that he “tried to sound like a dry martini”. Amazing relaxed lyricism with none of the urgency of Brecker. Jim Hall !!!

https://youtu.be/DS51jwmqpO4?si=pXv_bwonhgkVL-pB

Between two Michael Brecker exploration ...😊

I discovered this album and an interesting trio of European jazz :

Rein De Graaff piano trio

This De Graaf plays a lot with sax players ...baritone sax here by Ronnie Cuber is outstanding ...

I will search other De Graaff albums ...And Ronnie Cuber too ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6sPN93jf5Q&list=OLAK5uy_kVeaGHKfd6e4ggi9GKlGlNKLK111hIqXg

Thanks i will check for sure...😉

I am in love with trombone and sax baritone ...😊

 

@mahgister Here is a couple more with multiple baritones

Line for Lyons - YouTube

Blowing The Blues Away - YouTube

 

There is something soothing and relaxing in the Baritone sax voice, and Gary Smulyan is very good at it, and we need relaxation these days 😁 :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ja6Yep7lf3g&list=PLdFOkuVvI1yx6OYh8TSEx19zPDRQn9vAX&index=2

 Waiting from other Brecker surprizes i listen to Gary Smulyan a third  magnificent album here  all about sax but dominated by the baritone of Smulyan :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-8xu14NDjc&list=PLdFOkuVvI1ywgWOCpfKADglkPlrfY3gWy

 

 

Thanks frogman for the musical precisions ...

You are our living jazz master and teacher here...😊

I will go for Pepper Adams too ...

I swim in an ocean of trombone , sax, and baritone now ....many albums to discover are coming in the next months ...

The trumpet and piano and guitars i love so much has now many instruments rivals in my heart...

I begin to appreciate bass too because of the clarity of my actual  headphone and speakers  system with bass ...

My respect and appreciation for your help ... ...

@mahgister , you’ve mentioned two of the greatest baritone players. I am particularly a fan of Ronnie Cuber, who is sadly no longer with us. Monster baritone prayer, While Smulyan is a great post-bebopper through and through, Ronnie Cuber was more akin to Micheal Brecker in the sense that he did a lot of work in the R&B and Latin music scenes as well as straight ahead Jazz. As expected all that was reflected in his playing.. I love his playing.

https://youtu.be/zWw-3kJwge0?si=aUM0y5nnd36K8GwQ

Some favorite earlier work of his:

https://youtu.be/d89efDn97qs?si=47ffeSAiCgDUwcVf

https://youtu.be/5bypNuFs9oc?si=n61GImad0Cg1lcI6

No conversation on baritone players should overlook the greatest of all, Pepper Adams. A close listen to Smulyan’s sound and approach shows how he is a musical descendant of the great Pepper Adams, whom he replaced in the Thad Jones/Mel Lewis Orchestra saxophone section,

https://youtu.be/fjm52JRscpA?si=eGEv2PwrSV_nUF2v

https://youtu.be/4lKTp8u6YSg?si=VknTidVRFxsb30Zs

As an interesting aside. At some point before recording the following, Pepper Adams had to replace his saxophone mouthpiece. The difference in tone is obvious. Still great and still Pepper Adams, but with more edge:

https://youtu.be/tOCZddFI1tU?si=mGp726OzBq32xJEV

https://youtu.be/lg7Hm5aE8mI?si=Yy-zKUNf7AjXMqwi

 

Thanks for this one it seems interesting...

I dont know why i like baritone so much ...

I like bass human voices and contralto feminine voice also ....😁

 

Charles Davis is another good baritone saxophonist. You can hear him on this album:

https://youtu.be/3JIlzhYs5iI?si=wSpYaZ6TJ7LG-jhC

I had the good fortune to hear Gary Smulyan live with the Dave Holland big band a few years ago. He had maybe 4 solos during the show, all well done.

 

This album with Smulyan is a gem ;

Three sax baritone for the price of one ,one is Ronnie Cuber 😁:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bbMSg3I1pg&list=OLAK5uy_kJmFAkgu-pIdwZ1TExMeuoUbSPhYaPDc0

 

My soundfield was never so good ...I cannot stop listening music...

Save for my embeddings control efficiency i dont understand why , because my self active speakers are not top speakers as My Tannoy were ... But i was knowing nothing for the 45 years i owned them and i never listened to them at their top in an acoustic room as i know how to do now with my low cost speakers whyich i optimized a lot  for sure ...

I cannot stop music ....

 
 

 

 

I dont understand how this low cost active speakers i own  can be so good ... It is my successful embeddings controls and modifications for sure , what else ?

I disliked these speakers for 12 years straight and never used them for music till i was in the obligation to modify and embed them for music because they were the only one i owned now ..

I cannot stop listening and i pity many of those who own 50,000 bucks speakers not well embedded ... 😁

 

For Gary Smulyan , it is a player with genius in my book not less than Ronnie Cuber ...And i prefer his musical choices ( more classic jazz)  too even if i like the two players ...

You cannot go wrong with any Smulyan albums it seems to me ...

 

 

@mahgister

I cannot stop listening music...

You must be doing something right with your embedding!

 

And this one is no less good :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lh6JpSt9Yko&list=PLBJenJIJrq0zaurEPd-ssmOXR43HyQx6J

Smulyan is very gifted ...

I’m going to have to buy this!

For now as you i cannot pick one for a desert island..

They all sound good...

And i like not only his artistry on the instrument but the music he create  with it ...

😊

@mahgister 

 Been listening to Smulyan all day today and one album is better than the next.  I can see why you like his work.

Just right now i listen anew the "trouble" album of Jamie Saft...

This dude make original jazz music ...But unlike Smulyan it is an acquired taste ... 😁

It begun to enter in my collection of favorite with some albums ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NRLDg-413Aw&list=OLAK5uy_ng8sGrK1U7Q_B3etC7NAmJUGyGPoZAr2A

 

Sometimes less is more ...

This album of Jamie Saft is relaxing,

And as his title indicate "Doom Jazz" more than perfect for me to read the news on twitter, if not there on X ,where ? ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oNo1Tz8yOZc&list=OLAK5uy_liDS2NGpoa9Yk_hEZtj9Oh8cc1Oc_0SPo

I dont recommend it for purchase but i am very happy ti listen to it on youtube...

I like Jamie Saft sorry...

 

 

I must confess that i dislike most jazz singer save very few...

I had listen the album "trouble" for the music variation on Dylan melodies... Not for the spoken songs ...😁

I prefer Dylan over most singer in the pop culture and in the jazz culture singing ...

Then i think the same as you ...

but i like the Saft albums in general ...It is not classical jazz for sure ...

 

@mahgister

Tastes differ. Why apologize?

Not sure this qualifies as Jazz but there’s nothing to be gained through nitpicking.

Personally, if I’m going to listen to the likes of "Ballad of a Thin Man", I’d rather listen to Dylan’s original version. Neither Dylan nor the vocalist on the Saft recording are "good" singers but I prefer Dylan’s "bad" singing. It seems to me, some songs are best left alone, as cover versions inevitably fall short.

Having said that, I’m glad you’ve found another musician you enjoy !

Today is my Joey DeFrancesco  hammond player day and multi instrumentist ...

I discovered him thanks to czarivey audiogon member  recommendation ...

I like hammond organ jazz...

I could not recommend an album in particular, they seems all interesting ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=230SAX-zDTk&list=RDEMcVCLWgzE84AMExDBDakaXw&start_radio=1

 

 

 

Another day with among others i already named here, Joey DeFrancesco :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-S6rJo_ANs&list=OLAK5uy_no0K1TBhG05V4EV56mg57BJdFald2X1ic

 

Just fun and relaxing jazz on Hammond with guitar, a coupling i particularly enjoy ...

We need relaxation ...😊

I am so enthralled by my acoustic corner with these low cost modified speakers so good the soundfield is that i dont believe it myself ...

Definitely  the minimal acoustical satisfaction level may be lower in cost than i ever dreamed it myself ...

Immersive music on all my files ... Timbre are natural and soundstage encompassing me in many recording with perfect imaging ...

I cannot stop listening jazz....

With one hour classical each day ...

 

Hammond cheese,eggs + bacon in maple syrup .... The real maple syrup ...

😉

@mahgister 

Hammond cheese or Hammond eggs? ? ? 

Ouff! too much good stuff in two posts ...

Anyway thanks for all propositions .,..

I myself go on today with Joey Defrancesco ....It is not Coltrane or Brecker ...Perhaps not Smulyan or Saft ...

He is not in the same high level jazz than some, only good jazz easy to metabolise ...

I listen sometimes easy jazz .... 😁

Hammond rule my heart anyway ...

😉

There is too many great jazz albums for one lifetime but this one is certainly one to add :

Jazz Times Superband: Music: Bob Berg Randy Brecker Dennis Chambers Joey DeFrancesco

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DqMy_6q7xk0

Pure honey or maple syrup ; Michael Brecker and Joey DeFrancesco hammond ...But i dont know if this album exist ... I know one with Randy Brecker i recommended above ...😊

 

By the way this album is stunningly good for Hammond lovers ;

Jack McDuff · Joey DeFrancesco It's About Time :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhZTQqm2jOA&list=OLAK5uy_nmL9BYph5NKe-Rxp2Ecnru2OQiYBLcgNo

Great indeed!

It seems there is many albums with Humair ...

I will look thanks stuartk ..

Daniel Humair: Cool Trading with Attila Zoller and Mike Formanek - YouTube

This one with Daniel Humair  is more than just good it seems ... Rava is one of my favorite trumpet player in europe ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cz2scNFI0Co

 Another great winning album by joey DeFrancesco ...

Amazing musician for me especially on the Hammond ..

The Champ · Joey DeFrancesco

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dhb6mGr5tBI&list=OLAK5uy_mE2kryuuS4kuMgls9f3fx5mv4D5cNv9zo

Thanks for the suggestion ...

I put them in the waiting list ... I admire Sun Ra ...

Here are my two favorites from Sun Ra. I have both of these titles on a single CD.

Angels and Demons at Play

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_kyWMotl9H9oM0TXHPuqHwbWXWYyEtdMl8&si=witeb1Y4B5rItaBX

The Nubians of Plutonia

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLGX_iebp2Prk18FG7qp_rw2gTBmNWAKSB&si=QlbO-mU-rc3CG8vv

The picture of the album is beyond kitsch ...😁

But Joey DeFrancesco play the Hammond better than most ...

My favorite music to relaxing casual listening reading the news ...

This does not means that this is not good music ...😊

Another album to enjoy :

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zagj_yiNxDg&list=OLAK5uy_l4QcAHIohQsfa_xtFNH-kN20kUyXP6bzQ

 

Very good recommendation ...

I concur with it ..😉

Tsuyoshi Yamamoto Trio

 

If you buy one album of DeFrancesco on hammond , this album with a good sax sound and playing is one of his best...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F89Pu9m6JGM

There is many good jazz pianist indeed...

But as good not so much...

As i said for me he is the Spanish Bill Evans ...

Or the spanish Oscar Peterson... Not less ...

 

Not only his bass and drummer are exceptional but the sound quality let them be such ...

Dont upgrade your system... It exist at least 50 albums to buy ... 😊

 

 

 

I take a break between two Tete Montoliu albums ...

The more i listen the more i like him...

 

I listen to the spiritual jazz series 12 albums , this one is the 7th  :