My opinion, there are two aspects of "a recording". Probably more. The Technical and the Performance.
There is a YouTube video claiming "the best 'recording' of Chopin...." Horowitz's performance was impeccable. The recording was horrible. A Casio electric piano with its 3" speakers comes to mind.
A poorly performed piece will never pass. No matter how well recorded.
Yes, the Technical very important. But don't forget the Artist's performance. I may forgive a poor recorded piece for an exceptional Performance. Lol, but there is a limit to how much I will forgive.