Is there a clear winner???

I think I've narrowed it down to Revel F50's and Silverline Sonata III? I understand all speakers have their own unique sonic traits and characteristics. From what I've read I believe both of these speakers are superb products for their price, although I have not heard either. If I had a chance to A-B them what could I expect? Are they completely different or similar with subtle differences? I would like to hear well defined accoustic guitar, crisp highs and vocals without bordering on bright, absolutely NOTHING harsh, and once in a while some "punch you in the chest" bass. I will be running a Mcintosh MC352 in 2 channel stereo. Thanks ahead if time for any or all replies !!!