Is a Tube Amp Capable of High Current?


I need your help.

I have a pair of VERY inefficient speakers (Platinum Solos), but am also a big fan of tubes. I know that tubes can work with power-hungry speakers as I have done it with a pair of Magnepans...BUT...I'm not certain that it will work in this case.

The speakers are rated at 84db with a nominal impedence of 6 ohms.

I am purchasing an Audio Research D-125 which is rated at 115wpc.

I know that people always say that "tube watts" are more powerful than solid state watts, but I'm not really sure what that means. I also always hear people say that you need a "high current" amp. I've always taken this to refer to solid state, but can this be true of tube amps as well? Is the ARC D-125 high current?

I'm not a head-banger and certainly prefer quality over quantity when it comes to sound. Also, my room is not particularly huge, so that shouldn't be too big of a factor.

I need your advice. Am I setting myself up for disappointment? Does a load like this inherently require solid state amplification?

Thanks!
dan53e1

Showing 3 responses by ghostrider45

Tube amps (except OTL types) use an output matching transformer. This transformer presents (relatively) fixed impedance (usually settable to 4, 8 or 16 ohms) to the speakers. The Matching Theorem (see any good EE circuits textbook) says that a source (i.e. amp) with fixed output impedance supplies maximum power when the load (i.e. speaker) has the same impedance.

Thus tube amps normally don't do well with demanding loads with impedances that vary across the audio spectrum. For example, when the speaker is attached to the 4 ohm tap on the amp, it gets maximum power when its impedance is also 4 ohms. Most speaker impedances vary across the audio spectrum, so power delivered to the speaker also varies with frequency. This effect is partly responsible for some of the tube sound.

Another way to look at it is that the inherent impedance of the transformer limits the current.

We can turn the matching theorum around, and ask what source (amp) output impedance delivers the most power to a given load (speaker). In this case, the lower the source impedance, the more power you get into a given load.

Transistor amps normaly don't have output transformers (there are a few exceptions). They tend to have very low output impedances. Many, (especially those built with massive power supplies and running class A) have output impedance much less than an ohm and can deliver large amounts of current into low impedance loads.

So if you need lots of current, solid state is the way to go. You can get there with tubes, but you need a lot of them, and massive (expensive) output transformers to go with them. They still supply maximum power only at the selected output impedance, though.
As long as your nominally 6 ohm speakers don't have any dramatic impedance dips or peaks, I think the ARC's will do fine. Use the 4 ohm tap - it's better to mismatch the load on the high side of the amp output impedance rather than the low side. You'll effectively lose about 20% of potential output power.

Given the nominal nature of speaker impedance and output impedance, I doubt you'll notice any difference.

BTW Ralph - The equivalent circuit for the amp looks like am ideal voltage source in series with an impedance. This impedance represents the output impedance of the amp. It can limit current into low impedance loads since it is in series with the speaker.

Also, for those whose math is rusty, when dealing with alternating current (i.e. audio signals) the voltage, current, and impedance are complex quantities (i.e. each is in the form a+bi, where i = sqrt(-1) ). For impedances, the imaginary part is the reactive component, and the real part is the resistive component. Complex arithmetic models the energy storage behavior of capacitive and inductive elements in the circuit.
Dan - I think you'll be OK. The speaker seems reasonably well behaved and the 4 ohm taps should do fine.

Enjoy.