My friend has some inexpensive focal bookshelf speakers, purchased as an upgrade on even cheaper KEF speakers. He is new to audio but could afford much better speakers if he wanted them. I encouraged him to audition some ls3/5 type speakers and he did so. We did some a/b testing. I found the focals to be dangerously colored and flashy, obscuring a lot of the music and emphasizing others; he found that ls3/5s boring. He liked the sizzly treble and bigger bass. He stuck with the focals. Because I'm a snob, I think he should like the ls3/5s better, but that's my problem, not his.
OP, you like what you like. Give the new speakers a chance but get rid of the pair you like less and feel less motivated to listen to.
OP, you like what you like. Give the new speakers a chance but get rid of the pair you like less and feel less motivated to listen to.