I've been going through this dilemma as well (new guy, one year deep in this hobby. Although I've loved music forever). I separated the two entirely, yesterday, so I am delighted to see your post this morning. And I agree with that millercabon dude... he speaks the truth.
I have a Denon x4500 AVR (similar to your Marantz I think, and had great reviews for music listening) and bought speakers last year thinking I'd get the best of both worlds... However, after setting up dedicated 2-channel listening in the den with with suggestions from audiophile forums like this for a year, my super awesome HT setup did not sound so awesome anymore for music, and that was becoming my priority. I upgraded power cords, RCA cables, separate amp for the 2 front towers... it all helped but it was still missing something truly musical (not sure how else to describe it).
To confess, I was trying to force 2-channel perfection through a pair of Def Tech BP9060 towers. I know, NOT great speakers for what I want from music... I lived and learned. But for HT... THEY ROCK with the Denon.
So, as of yesterday, I am now sitting in front of a new pair of Wharfedale EVO 4.4's, connected to a new, separate 100 wpc Yamaha integrated amp, with a CD player and music streamer hooked up to that. I still have the entire Def Tech/Denon set up as well, but only my Blu-ray and TV are connected. (And if I want, I can hook up the TV via optical to the integrated amp for Christmas morning fire place jazz on youtube :))
NIGHT and DAY difference. I couldn't be happier and I did not spend all that much money, comparatively speaking, to get the best of both worlds.
I think knowing what I know now, I'd have gone this route from the beginning. Playing music is easy. Less buttons and settings to press/adjust, and one less interconnect from music source to speakers.
I'd look into separating the two "experiences" as much as you can.
Pink Floyd's "The Wall" sounds more beautiful and alive this morning than I've ever heard in my life. Mission accomplished! And everything is just getting warmed up.
Have fun with it.
Brian
I have a Denon x4500 AVR (similar to your Marantz I think, and had great reviews for music listening) and bought speakers last year thinking I'd get the best of both worlds... However, after setting up dedicated 2-channel listening in the den with with suggestions from audiophile forums like this for a year, my super awesome HT setup did not sound so awesome anymore for music, and that was becoming my priority. I upgraded power cords, RCA cables, separate amp for the 2 front towers... it all helped but it was still missing something truly musical (not sure how else to describe it).
To confess, I was trying to force 2-channel perfection through a pair of Def Tech BP9060 towers. I know, NOT great speakers for what I want from music... I lived and learned. But for HT... THEY ROCK with the Denon.
So, as of yesterday, I am now sitting in front of a new pair of Wharfedale EVO 4.4's, connected to a new, separate 100 wpc Yamaha integrated amp, with a CD player and music streamer hooked up to that. I still have the entire Def Tech/Denon set up as well, but only my Blu-ray and TV are connected. (And if I want, I can hook up the TV via optical to the integrated amp for Christmas morning fire place jazz on youtube :))
NIGHT and DAY difference. I couldn't be happier and I did not spend all that much money, comparatively speaking, to get the best of both worlds.
I think knowing what I know now, I'd have gone this route from the beginning. Playing music is easy. Less buttons and settings to press/adjust, and one less interconnect from music source to speakers.
I'd look into separating the two "experiences" as much as you can.
Pink Floyd's "The Wall" sounds more beautiful and alive this morning than I've ever heard in my life. Mission accomplished! And everything is just getting warmed up.
Have fun with it.
Brian