Help with Hi Power Tube Amp Selection


I'm looking for some help in making up my mind (since auditioning will be impossible). I will be replacing my integrated amp (an Electrocompaniet ECI-4SE) with high powered monblock tube amps. The ones I'm considering are (in order of preference):

VTL 450 Sigs
ASL Hurricanes
Manley 250 Neo-Classic
Wolcott Presence 220

I've heard the Manleys, and like them a lot. I've heard lesser iterations of the VTLs, which also sounded good to me. The other two got awesome reviews. I love that big tube sound.

Here's the rest of my components:

Von Schweikert VR-4 III SE Speakers
BAT VK-D5 CDP w/ NOS Amperex Bugle Boys 6DJ8
BAT VK-5i or VK-30SE Preamp (also undecided)
Audience AU24 XLR Interconnects
AZ Satori Shotgun Speaker Cables

So, from your experiences, what would be the best fit in tube monoblocks?

Thanks!
1markr

Showing 1 response by albertporter

I have only heard the VTL and Wolcott. They are different in their presentation. The VTL is more traditional tube sound, but I don't mean too warm or slow. The VTL is excellent, better yet the Signature series 750 mono blocks.

The Wolcotts are almost as controlled as a big solid state amp, but with (only) tube personality. This is due to a patented design by Hank Wolcott. If you are fond of the control solid state provides for your speakers but want tubes, the Wolcott may be the best match.

For absolute "slam" factor and seemingly unlimited power, the big VTL would probably be the winner.

I don't know how you react to tube maintenance, but of the amps your considering, only the Wolcott is auto bias and digests every EL 34 made, making tube selections a delight.

If your using the balanced out from your BAT, the Wolcott has a convenience jack for balanced. This might save you converting the plugs. A minor thing, but a consideration.