Help? Quadraspire Q4 Evo stand v SolidTech Radius?


I have an opportunity to buy one of of these racks.

Quadra is a 4 shelf, and the Solid Tech Radius (Solo) is a 3 shelf.

Which would you take purely for its sound qualities / isolation abilities? (Looks are secondary for me.)

I'm looking for a stand that keeps a fairly neutral presentation and doesn't warm/smooth up the sound or make things bright..

Thanking you for your thoughts!

Andrew
rippingtonblue

Showing 2 responses by rippingtonblue

Hi guys

Sorry for the delay in responding to this - thought audigon emailed you when someone responded to posts - guess not!! Thought nobody replied=).

Well, I ended up buying a very good value and mint condition used Quadraspire Q4 Evo. Mostly because the price was literally 1/3rd the cost of the Solid Tech. Just assembling it now and will reply/post a review as to my thoughts.

thank you for responding it helped greatly!!

Andrew
Hi all,

Well.. I just wanted to provide an update on this, and obtain your thoughts ?

I recently acquired (at a great price) a Quadraspire Q4 Evo stand. In short, it has some good sound aspects and, some negatives (compared to my older, cheap, but sand/leadshot filled rack).

Positives : Very musical, rhythmic, and neutral in tonality. Music DVD's are very enjoyable.

The negatives : (And these are big ones to me) - the dynamics, and bass.

It's strange - compared to my 15 yr old rack (Goldring - 50/50 sand and lead filled rack - a no-name rack brand as far as I've researched), I've found the Quadraspire Q4 Evo to be very bass-shy, and lacking in dynamics. Case in point - playing a 5.1 Surround Blu Ray Disc on my Quadraspire I actually had to check my subwoofers to make sure they were working. They were ; I measured them with an SPL meter to confirm. During a movie soundtrack though, very bass and dynamic-shy ; obviously so in comparison to my old sand/lead filled rack.

Long story short - the Quadraspire Q4 Evo I've just bought is back on the market. I love music on this stand but, movie-watching is a very underwhelming experience as far as dynamics and bass are concerned.

Have any other owners of similar UK-style ('lighter-is-better') racks, found the above observations? Or, not..? I'd love to hear of others' thoughts.

After this experience I'm wondering if I should go to a Solid Steel, or Solid Tech stand - ie, one that is mass-loadable. I know when I mass-loaded my old rack the bass and sound improved substantially - more powerful/tighter bass, dynamics, etc.

In short, maybe this was just a purchase down the wrong path. Perhaps I should have gone with a mass-loadable rack ie, the American style mass-loading 'heavier-is-better' school of thought. I say this on the basis that my old rack (filled 50/50 with sand/lead shot) absolutely destroys this new Quadraspire in the areas of bass power and dynamics.

Sigh.. stands and racks. Such a difficult guessing game.

Any input would be appreciated!!

Thanks