Good Grief. Another Tchaikovsky already.


.
Tchaikovsky's violin concerto in D Major is the tool that many classical music lovers use to evaluate violinists. If he or she does the Tchiakovsky to your liking you will probably like recordings by the same artist of other less familiar pieces. Over the years I have acquired a number of recordings. My favorite is Russian David Oistrach, recorded in 1954...mono, but good mono. His absolute mastery and power is inspiring so that his occasional technical defects are of no consequence. A Korean woman, Kyung Wha Chung plays in similar style with fewer errors on a stereo recording. Close but not quite there. Itzhak Perlman, in his youth, gave it a good shot.

But now I have found a new recording that is poles apart from Oistrach, but which I find striking. I recommend Sony Classical SH 94822, a SACD, Joshua Bell, with the Berlin Philharmonic, Michael Tilson Thomas conducting. This was recorded barely a year ago, and benefits from excellent recording technology. But it is the performance, recorded during a concert, that makes it worth buying this disc no matter how many other Tchaikovskys you have filed away. The interpretation is lyrical, which is dangerous because it could come out like mush, but Bell pulls it off to perfection. The lyrical approach is definitely not a cover for technical weakness, as is sometimes the case. IMHO, his performance provides new insights which, for an old warhorse like the Tchaikovsky is hard to do.

Others may not like the interpretation, but it sure is different, and well worth a listen.
.
eldartford

Showing 3 responses by eldartford

Check out Bell's web site...joshuabell.com. Of particular interest is the lengthy writeup about the history of the Strad he plays.
Sugarbrie...Agree about Hillary Hahn. Quite apart from the less than spectacular performance I find the Multichannel mix to be aweful. With a center channel to work with they cut poor Hillary in half and put the pieces in Left and Right, with almost nothing in the center channel. How this disc won a prize escapes me.

My violin has a small burnt spot at the edge of the top, where I set it down too close to a candle. Will this increase its value?
Texasdave...It would be interesting to compare his approach in 1988 with today. I think I must have a Heifetz somewhere. I will dig it out and listen.