I have read positive things about the PS Audio GCPH and believe it is still a viable piece in a good system plus it has the vol. control. But I think your peachtree offers lots of flex and I wouldnt abandon the heart of your system...yet. If it were my choice, I would opt for a used table, new cartridge and used phono, similar to what Heyraz suggests. I would look for used Sota Comet, P3, MF5.1. I would then put a new cart-like Ortofon 2M red (blue if you can swing it). it comes with a scale and instructions so you can install it yourself. 100-200, respectively. A used NAD pp2 or creek mm $100.
Or get a new project Carbon, comes with Ortofon 2M red mounted for $399 or $499. Read michael fremer's review. He paired it with a Bellari tubed phono preamp and liked the results. Any cash left over spend on new vinyl and accesories like a record brush.
Or get a new project Carbon, comes with Ortofon 2M red mounted for $399 or $499. Read michael fremer's review. He paired it with a Bellari tubed phono preamp and liked the results. Any cash left over spend on new vinyl and accesories like a record brush.