A 250 watt amp driven into mild clipping could easily heat the voice coil more than 350 watts peak of clean music signal.
What Elevick was told is however an exaggeration. It is heat, not a clipped waveform per se, that is damaging. From a thermal power handing standpoing, a clipped waveform simply means the average wattage (heat) going into the voice coil is much closer to the maximum wattage that the amp can put out. 500 watts peak unclipped might be ballpark 50 watts average (depends on the music of course), which is far higher than 1 watt clipped.
What Elevick was told is however an exaggeration. It is heat, not a clipped waveform per se, that is damaging. From a thermal power handing standpoing, a clipped waveform simply means the average wattage (heat) going into the voice coil is much closer to the maximum wattage that the amp can put out. 500 watts peak unclipped might be ballpark 50 watts average (depends on the music of course), which is far higher than 1 watt clipped.