Ethernet patch panel and network switch question


Guys,

I have an ethernet patch panel in my office that I'm running ethernet to my Antipodes K40 music server.  I've been reading a lot about the NA EVO ethernet passive filter and am on the verge of pulling the trigger.  However, it seems that everyone recommends a network switch from the router.  My router is 2 floors down into the basement.  Do I need to run a switch from the patch panel on the wall to the ENO and then to the K40?  Do I need a switch at all?  TBH, I have no idea what the switch would do.  I'm asking b/c lots of folks are talking about the benefits of using a switch before the ENO.  Thanks.


Bill

wtb

Showing 5 responses by david_ten

Unless you need to connect other LAN components in your office (which need to communicate to each other), a network switch is likely ’overkill’ for your specific application (i.e. solely for the Antipodes K40).

However, if you are prioritizing sound quality improvements it may make a difference. Make sure you are using decent LAN cable from your basement’s router to the office. Hopefully you are doing that already. If you are not, then I recommend doing so first...before you start adding on passive filters, a switch, etc. [Note: go direct from the router (I'm assuming you have an extra LAN port on it) to the K40. In other words, do not run that cable via your patch panel]

@nmolnar ’s suggestion to look into a fiber optic solution is a good one.

There are many ways to approach this. I believe you will be able to improve your sound quality. One example, having a separate (dedicated) network for your music streaming (separate from your other home and office requirements).

@wtb Bill, I was addressing the switch specifically.

No harm in trying out the passive ENO, or any other for that matter.

In your situation, I would choose an active filter. Primarily since (I assuming) your patch panel is using standard install wiring; it is an unnecessary added ’interface’: and because it is likely ’more detrimental’ than you realize: for music.

The last point is why I suggested running a fresh and direct line. What makes that not doable, in your situation?

Given your building’s history and restrictions....

It’s been an issue since I bought the building last year and we still haven’t found an acceptable work around. 

ALL electrical and networking wires are foamed in place.  This has caused problems for us as we can't upgrade anything.

 

Have you given thought to setting up a Mesh Network? It’s a solution for the audio side (and has broader application if you want it to).

Run a short length of ethernet cable from the Mesh Network Satellite to your K40.

The K40 was one of the options I was considering. It’s a great unit. I have a feeling it’s potential is being hobbled by your current setup.

You can still use the ENO filter after the Satellite, should you want to and should it add to overall performance.

@wtb run a google search

What is a mesh network?

 

Do you have a modem that feeds your router or a router that is both modem and router? I’m assuming a modem since you are running your ethernet lines through the patch panel. Assuming along these lines: Modem - Managed Switch - Patch Panel (in the basement).

If you have a modem:

Modem > Mesh Router (into the unit’s WAN;  this can be in your basement or elsewhere if you have an available direct line to your modem > Mesh Satellite (this will sit in your office) > Mesh Satellite’s LAN port > Antipodes K40

[Note: some Mesh Satellites are set up identical to the main unit, in other words they also have a WAN connection option]

Since I don’t know your ISP (and type; cable/fiber/other) and what type of router you are using, PM me with specific info.

There are a number of brands of Mesh Routers available. I use Netgear’s Orbi Pro for my audio network. I also have the ASUS AX6600. You will find a number of summary comparisons, reviews, and quick pointers for best model for specific application online.