DIY speakers vertical array a la "pipedreams" syst


Have any of you worked on a multi drivers vertical array type of speakers ...something that would look like a diminutive version of the http://www.nearfieldacoustics.com/The%20System.htm systems ?

What were the results?

i have a suddent interest in knowing why so many people
prefer this kind of setup to systems of equivalent quality drivers/enclosures with less in number ...

Anyone has a good ressource for buying excellent drivers
( only the drviers ) and or reviews of such ?

i will need a 15-18" driver for my sub neway , even
if i still go with ESLs ..

But the vertical array systems attract me for a single reason, build is easy and it should cost equivalent to electrostatics ( since no need for $$$$ step up transformer
but multi drivers need to be purchased ..

I would be considering a desing of a few feet tall with a
front face of 12" to 18" maybe with an opened rear for dipole action since they can't reach the front in their resonnat frequency ...mmmm

could be something in the 3 feet tall in total
wonder how many driver i could place on that :p

what do you guys think?

then also, about the need to drive all the drivers,
will it ask for a really powerfull amplification ?
or since all the drivers are working less powerfull to
attain the equivalent sound pressure, they thus require less power ?

what do you think of nerafield acoustic theory that
having more drivers permits the drivers to be worked at lower power and drivers are more accurate at lower power?

thanks for your time,

anything will help :)
jinmtvt

Showing 5 responses by albertporter

Looks like an incredible project and priced where most anyone can afford a pair. I like the web site too, with the ability to click and view all the stages of Fred's progress as he cut and assembled, all the way to the final product with improved tweeter.

Makes me wish I needed another pair of speakers.
Essentialaudio, agreed, but the FredArray looks like (after quick calculations) to top out around $750.00 for the pair (plus sweat equity). That's less than a pair of Vandy 2's.

The idea is not to compete with Pipedreams, they already have their reputation established. This is a hobby site and hopes to involved people with hands on projects. I hope he catches on, we need more converts to high end.
Essentialaudio, I don't disagree with your priorities, I just don't expect everyone has the budget for a top tier speaker.

Getting a young guy or gal into a DIY speaker that keeps the light burning for high end is a very worthwhile idea.

When I was very young, I began with a budget of $129.00 to built my first amp and preamp for my dream stereo system. If my only option had been something "world class," I would have never ventured into high end. I could not have afforded it.

That's all I meant.
Yep, considered that design and did research. My trip to NYC to cover HE 2004 for Audiogon stimulated me even more.

The Epiphany with Tenors really got me going:

http://www.epiphanyaudio.com/

Then I found this designer (here, near Dallas) who offers very reasonable kits and access to fancy cabinets.

http://www.gr-research.com/AlphaLS/Alpha.htm

Considering these are ribbon top end, very efficient to drive and great looking, this could be exactly what your looking for. Good luck.
The GR Research people sell a well designed kit (link provided in my previous post) and include plans for the cabinet. You could email or call about open back design and see what his experience is.

As for shopping, I thought the price was great. $1995.00 for 16 BG ribbon assemblies and 18 woofers, plus all the crossover parts. You might do better but this way the design is worked out and leaves the creative cabinet, finish and other fun stuff to you.

I even considered this for myself I though it was such a good deal. I really don't need them since I already own Soundlab U-1's but the fun factor attracts me.

As for performance, I have not heard the kit but the Epiphany speakers showed great promise, even under show conditions.