DIY Replacing Components in Crossovers


I have a couple pair of old speakers that I'm thinking about tinkering around with by replacing existing capacitors and/or resistors with different brands just to get a taste of how different higher quality parts affect the speaker's sound. I don't have any interest in redesigning the crossover networks, only to replace existing parts with better quality parts with the same values to see what kind of results I get. Soldering and the mechanics of replacing the parts isn't an issue for me but I just don't have much experience with the sonics of individual parts. Have any of you done this before? What has worked for you? All things being equal, do you hear much difference replacing crossover parts with better quality components? Any stories to tell? Thanks for looking.

 

arch2

Showing 1 response by gererick

Grannyring, bought a number of Duelund CAST PIO caps as part of a crossover upgrade. These caps are out of stock most places.

So for the midrange section, where I need 13.0uF, I bought 8.2 + 4.7 + 0.1 for one speaker and 8.2 + 3.3 + 1.5 for the other speaker.

The Duelund CAST PIO 100 Vdc caps are disk shaped, with greater uF values (like 8.2 in my case) having modestly greater height or thickness than lesser values like 4.7uF, but the roughly 7” diameter is the same for the two values just mentioned and I think for the 3.3 as well.

It seems to me that the only real option is to put the caps on top on each other, like layers in a layer cake. The leads come out of the top of the caps, close to the outside of the disk-shaped caps. So I would need some sort of spacers so that the top caps aren’t resting on the leads of the cap underneath.

I will also need a way to secure the caps to the board. I don’t like the idea of plastic ties per se, and might be more interested in a bolt screwed through the board with the thread end toward the ceiling, and some sort of clip. Several bolts / clips per cap. I may end up having to settle for plastic ties, though.

I won’t have this problem for the woofer section, where I will be using Auricap XO+ (a brand new ‘uptier’ from the XO which HHHiFi rated 11 vs 15 for the Duelunds that I selected for the other sections), or one of the tweeter caps. The other tweeter cap is 5.6 + 0.22 + 0.22 to get to close to 6.0, so I think only the 13.0 need in the midrange section needs a solution.

Any thoughts on how to best put 8.2 + 4.7 + 0.1 on the one board and 8.2 + 3.3 + 1.5 on the other, and whether stacking the discs on top of one another might cause performance issues due to the magnetic fields of each etc?