Disappointed in SACD player


Well, there I was yesterday. At the chain store who Sony has designated as their retail point of attack for SACD in the Philadelphia, PA region. Tweeter, formerly known as Bryn Mawr Stereo and Video. Formerly, Bryn Mawr Stereo(but we all know what happened there). Since my recent misfortunes with CD players, I was considering a jump to a Sony SACD player. One thing about Sony, their stuff is reliable. I found one player, the 5 disc changer. It was hooked up in a HT setup. Not even prominently. There was also another CD player in this system, along with a DVD-V player. As no salesman came into the room, I didn't pursue. I found no other player in the store. Finally, when we were looking at tv's, someone asked us if we needed help. I asked about SACD, and was told two players were on display. I asked to see the one that I didn't see. I was taken to a wall of DVD players, and sure enough, the ES9000 was there. Not hooked up, sitting there like all of the other DVD players. And in fact, THAT IS HOW THIS STORE IS MARKETING IT. As a DVD player! The guy gave me the big spiel on it, from a DVD perspective. 12 bit scan, instead of 10, etc., etc., etc. All of which is meaningless to me. I am not a HT or DVD guy. I spend my time on two channel audio. The guy left me less interested in the player than when I came in. They could not even find any SACD material in the entire store. Not even a sampler. I came in wanting to be impressed, wanting to leave with the desire to buy an SACD player. Needless to say, I probably won't be buying very soon. Wasn't this supposed to be Sony's summer of all out SACD offensive? Players starting at $350(which still will probably come), creating interest with the general public and lifting the new format to something beyond the niche of the lunatic fringe. As it is now, it is not even as recognizable as DAT, and miles behind MD(which was very prominent in the store). Both of which are monumental flops in the words of Sony.
trelja

Showing 2 responses by mdorsam

I have purchased most of my HT equipment (primarily B&K) at BMS. Dan Richardson, at their Towson, MD store, is the only one that knows this stuff cold. If you are really interested, then call him.

Facts are Facts, though, and correctly stated, above. Tweeter, in any and every form is not going to cater to the Audiophile: look at what they carry: Sony, which is not audiophile, Adcom and B&K: all mid-fi.
This is a good example of one company trying to dominate. I do appreciate a company or one person trying to dramatically improve the 'standard', but to then gouge based on that is not appropriate. For their (Beta-type) greed, I sincerely hope that DVD-A blows them away. Personally, I believe that DVD-A holds the greater promise, than SACD, but the DVD-A industry jumps on handgranades every chance it gets.