Directionality Explained


I have read it argued against by those who think they know
Here is proof
Paul Speltz Founder of ANTICABLES shares his thoughts about wire directionality. Dear Fellow Audiophiles, As an electronic engineer, I struggled years ago with the idea of wire being directional because it did not fit into any of the electrical models I had learned. It simply did not make sense to me that an alternating music signal should favor a direction in a conductor. One of the great things about our audio hobby is that we are able to hear things well before we can explain them; and just because we can’t explain something, doesn't mean that it is not real. 

https://www.monoandstereo.com/2020/05/wire-directionality.html#more
tweak1

Showing 27 responses by djones51

I'm  sure I would believe I hear a difference but at least I would know why. 
My wife the attorney has explained all this to me when I read some of this nonsense and ask why the devil can’t these crazy cable companies be sued. Nothing definitive, nothing actionable. Is Coke better than Pepsi or viseversa?
It made me sit by drawing me into that magical place only Benchmark DACs can do.
Anyway as any Reasonable Person would understand they are using the definition of sit as being harmonious with, not literally sit. Maybe cable companies should be sued as any Reasonable Person wouldn’t think changing the direction of a wire is going to open the soundstage and make the noise floor lower and more dark.
SIT IN THE PERFORMANCE SPACE

Transparent sound can go beyond replicating the studio experience. Recordings that have been produced with a natural and unprocessed sound can transport you to the performance space. Close your eyes and get ready to be transported!

There you go , close your eyes and be transported.
Does that mean you have nothing? No more idiotic comparisons where reasonable people know words in advertising can be used in ways besides the most common? 
People would be much better off generally speaking if they believed in too much rather than too little
They would be better off believing in reality and accepting their biases and understanding we all have them it's  not a human flaw just how we've evolved. 
"
significantly increase the range of both color and contrast, which creates an even more vibrant and realistic picture
." To who? Everyone? Couple hundred people? 10%of those who try it? You still are copying market speak approved by their lawyers. 
I don't want to sue anyone. To much trouble. 

No sit in the performance space is not actionable why the hell would anyone think it is? 
Listerine , J&J was already sued for their claim which is why they don't make the claim anymore. They even had to run adds for a number of years admitting their claim was false. The claim was" Listerine kills 99% of the germs that cause colds", of course they couldn't prove it and lost. 
LOL pretty much every state has some language recognizing implied warranties which has nothing to do with whether or not someone can hear differences in wires. 
It made me sit by drawing me into that magical sound only Benchmark can produce. See how easy it is? It's called marketing. 
9 out 10 dentists reccomend our toothpaste! Is that an actionable statement? No, the dentists I know reccomend basically any toothpaste plus which 9 out of 10? It's why you don't see 10 out of 10. 
I closed my eyes and was transported. You lose your lawsuit. You might want to get a better handle on actionable claims. Did they say everyone would be transported or would sit in the space? Did they say it would cure your audio nervosa?
If we're  going to use the Reasonable Person test cable companies better round up the wagons. I can't see the average guy in a jury noticing differences in wire direction or silver vs copper. Probably overturned on appeal though where it's judges looking at precedent. There's  a lot of leeway in advertising it's why there are so few successful lawsuits. 
The claims are absurd, factually unsubstantiated nor have a legal leg to stand on.

 Just advertising no worse than MSB or dCS and their overpriced stuff no better than a $700 ToppingD90
Oh yes any Reasonable person would think Benchmark means an actual studio is transported to your living room. Benchmark isn't dear to me I sold mine no better than the DAC in my integrated. They make good DACs though but so does a lot of companies. 
Maybe you are not a reasonable person.
True I'm  Probably no more reasonable than you. 
Eight Hybrid DACs.

With eight Hybrid DACs, we yield an unmatched level of detail, reproducing the musicality, soundstage, and texture of an original performance, bringing the artist to you.

WOW , MSB DACs can Bring the artist to my house? How great is that!

This is reasonable right? A reasonable person is going to assume this is what MSB means? 
Some IC and  speaker cables are specifically made to have a sound like a tone control. I would say all IC and speaker cable that measure very close would sound the same. 
I guess you could say imagination playing tricks, or our biases confirming what we believe. I have a bias that cables that measure similar sound the same. In a sighted test even if the cables have been altered to obviously sound different I would think they sound the same in an unsighted test I might be able to hear differences. It's just the way humans are wired,  all of us.
As the Chef says..We eat with our eyes. 
We also can hear with our eyes, it's how we're hard wired ...at least according to the professionals so I agree let's leave it to them.

>>>>Huh? Humans aren’t wired like that at all. Perhaps best to leave the psychological issues to the professionals

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/09/cognitive-bias/565775/
https://www.zmescience.com/science/cognitive-biases-list


James Johnston 
Acoustics, Psychoacoustics, Hearing - Architectural Acoustics

A view of perception Lateral inhibition Frequency filtering, loudness analysis Object Analysis Feature Analysis Cognitive-level understanding Peripheral Processing Megabits Many Megabits Kilobits Bits OBSERVE THE MASSIVE FEEDBACK AND THE LOSS OF DATA AT EACH STEP

How does this cause conflict? First, it clearly shows the need for “blind testing” in fact “double-blind testing”. – No, that doesn’t mean you wear a blindfold – It does mean that you have to detect the differences you’re listening for WITHOUT HINTS FROM OTHER SENSES No, you can’t ignore them. It’s not delusion, hallucination, or stupidity, it’s how your brain works. If it’s not a DBT, you have no idea what you were responding to, beyond “something.”