Dedicated 20 amp circuit - Electrician laughed!


I brought my electrician out to my house today to show him where I would like to install a dedicated 20a circuit for my system.  He laughed and said that's the stupidest thing he's heard and laughs when people talk about it.  It said, if you're going to do it, you have to have it separately grounded (shoving a new 8 foot rod into the ground) but even then, he sees no way there can be an audible improvement.

Now, he's not just an electrician though. He rebuilds tube amps on the side and tears apart amps and such all the time so he's quite well versed in audio electronics and how they operate.

He basically said anyone who thinks they hear a difference is fooling themselves.  

Personally, I'm still not sure, I'm no engineer, my room's not perfect, and I can't spend hours on end critical listening...  But, he does kinda pull me farther to the "snake oil" side and the "suggestive hearing" side (aka, you hear an improvement because you want to hear it).

I'm not taking a side here but I thought it was interesting how definitive he was that this not only WILL not make a difference but ALMOST CANNOT make a difference. 
dtximages

Showing 2 responses by papagiorgio

About 3 months ago I had two (my amps and sources are about 20 feet apart) dedicated 20 amp circuits installed into my audio/media room.  It did make a very noticeable improvement in reduced noise and distortion that comes through as much clearer imaging and soundstage.  For my system goals, I am trying to get live music to be more three dimensional and lifelike, and for that objective, this was one of the most significant upgrades that I have done.

I spec'd to the electrician to use 10AWG wiring, and Synergistic Blue outlets, which similar to OP also made him laugh.  At that time he told me that was total overkill, but he was happy to do the work if I wanted.  When the work was done, I had him listen to the difference with a simplistic A/B of moving power cables from a single shared 15A circuit to the two dedicated circuits, and he could clearly hear the difference.  What stood out to him most was that music sounded noticeably more realistic through the new 20A circuits.

For my system and home environment, this made a very large improvement, and it was one of the best ~$2,000 investments I have made.  I had a lot of AC noise issues with other devices on that shared 15A circuit, and separating my analog audio made a big difference.  If I had done just one 15A dedicated circuit, I think it would have done just as much improvement though.  I believe that the main benefit has come from not having my analog two channel gear sharing a single circuit with two Mac mini's, a NAS server, and some other digital devices with noisy SMPS's.  It may not make as much improvement for others, but for me this has been a great upgrade...
I like the added point that Dimorra made regarding separation of components onto separate legs at the breaker box.  When I did my setup, we specifically put the dedicated 20A "analog" circuits onto the second leg to keep them separate from the computers, servers, and LED lights.  It has also helped to have three separate panels with all kitchen appliances, HVAC, and utility room on the other two panels.  In my experience, I got the most improvement by getting as much separation as possible from electrically noisy home devices.