damping factor


i would like to know if a amp whit better damping factor than other one necessarily mean better bass punch? considering that they would have the same power.
thenis

Showing 4 responses by bombaywalla

05-27-11: Elizabeth
The damping factor is the 'control' the amp has of the woofer movement.
When the amp has a signal that moves the woofer and then the other way, the damping factor is the control the amp has to "HOLD" on to the cone and not allow it to continue going in the first direction, instead of obeying the amp and moving in the opposite immediately that the new signal wants. (sloppy explanation but it will do...

So "IF" your speakers have a BIG, 12" or maybe even a 10" sloppy woofer, the higher damping factor amp will 'control' it better, and that big sloppy woofer will behave better, giving a more solid punch, with less overhang and less woolly sound.
Where if you own a set of speakers with a single or pair of 'tight' 8" or 6" woofers, then the damping factor will not matter nearly as much, and other factors will overshadow the damping factor.
Generally it is said ANY solid state amp has enough damping factor to control any modern speaker system woofers. Only if you had some old speakers with giant woofers..
And the place where damping factor may be a little too small for some speakers is in a tube amp. Although the combo of a tube amp and big efficient speakers is usually heavenly, even if the bass is a little sloppy.
So all in all, you do not have to worry in any way about that particular spec called Damping factor. It is used to sell stuff, particularly amps which 'just by chance' have a particularly BIG damping factor, but it is a nearly meaningless spec.
there she goes again..............giving explanation on technical subjects she has no/little understanding!! Very similar situation to the "what is tube bias?" question posed not long ago by some other member.

Size of woofer cone has no bearing amp's ability to control woofer.
Slew rate is just as important(the amps ability to recover after a hard bass note).
I believe that you're correct - slew rate can give the buyer/user an idea of the power amp's bandwidth.
What you wrote was re. transient decay (post event) but slew rate is equally important for transient attack. Thanks.
05-27-11: Elizabeth
I guess guys in Bombay don't like chicks in there forums...
we do like women (I won't use "chicks" ...ahem!) in our forums Elizabeth (& those women do spell correctly too. Sorry that aspect was begging to be addressed. LOL! :-)) & they are always welcome but we'd like them to educate the public correctly on technical matters because in this particular case the subject matter is well-defined & documented & has a science-based explanation. Continuing to spread old wives tales keeps people uneducated which is never a good thing.
No major beef with you - you've been on this forum for as long (& maybe longer) than I have....