not sure what is being argued here...
@soix is a long time contributor, gives plenty of useful advice and is always careful to ask for enough info from those seeking advice before he gives it... to me, it is a ’best practice’ among those who frequent this site to share their views
as is being covered in another thread, it is useful when folks giving advice also share their experience level... the systems page can do that, or, for those who care to check, everyone’s past posts are right there to be seen with a few clicks
as usual, more transparency is better than less among users here, more experience is better than less in this pursuit, and on this forum where advice is sought and given both givers and recipients of advice or input should seek and provide clarity