I don't know your state but in a handful of states, including California, Michigan, and Nebraska, you must appear in small claims court on your own. (no lawyers allowed) Recording your conversation is hearsay. Hearsay evidence is normally excluded from a trial because it is deemed untrustworthy.
If you think he is responsible for the damage don't invite him to your home and just ignore him. If you feel, after talking to him that he is telling the truth you have the option to give him a refund.
If you think he is responsible for the damage don't invite him to your home and just ignore him. If you feel, after talking to him that he is telling the truth you have the option to give him a refund.