Choosing a cartridge for new turntable


Planning on replacing my turntable setup.  Currently have a Thorens TD125 MkII with Shure V15 type III cartridge.  Planning on getting a Dr Feickert Volare with Kuzma tonearm.  The dealer is recommending the following cartridges:

-Sumiko Blackbird

-Soundsmith Carmen

-Hana SL

I don't have experience with any of these brands.  Individual reviews use similar superlatives, and haven't come across any direct comparisons.  Anyone with experience using these that can comment on the sonic differences?  I would be happy to choose a cartridge similar in sound character to my current Shure. .

Thanks

arnoldo

Showing 3 responses by arnoldo

@big_greg That's the kind of comparison I was looking for thanks.  Interesting I was leaning towards either the Hana or Soundsmith based on reviews.  Think I'll focus further research on Soundsmith, seems to suit my tastes.  Any downsides to the Soundsmith in your opinion?

Also I do have have a JICO SAS stylus, it's great.

Yes, I think you're right, I'd probably like either one.  But going with Soundsmith based on how you describe it and it being more similar to Shure is a good rationale.  Especially since I'll probably be anxious with new turntable and all, will just make it less likely I question the purchase.  Maybe in a year or so may consider trying something different like the Hana.  Thanks.