Cheap tweak from Virtual Dynamics:


Has anyone seen the short video from Virtual Dynamics showing the owner replacing all his speaker screws with all brass screws? I was wondering if you could hear an improvement. It's a cheap tweak, so I thought I might go to Home Depot and try out a set. What can I lose?
sherod

Showing 5 responses by albertporter

This thread made me wonder if my Dali Megalines might benefit from torquing the woofer screws. The ribbons are suspended in space, so they are non adjustable.

I removed the top section grill cloth on each side (of the six sections) and located in my tool chest, the Torx star bit that fit the mounting screws.

I was surprised that with all my strength I was unable to tighten any of the screws on six woofers that I checked. Granted, I gave up before testing all 24 woofers, but it appears that in the case of this particular speaker the screws have not backed off, or perhaps the factory applied a bonding agent, set the torque and it resists further movement.

Whatever the case, it was a grand experiment and got me to vacuum those dusty grill cloths. I'm looking forward to reports from others on the benefit of this. I love cheap tweaks that have potential to improve sound.
Having been around audio for a long time and a past filled with car racing and engine building, when I say tighten with all my might I should have clarified the situation. Torx can be set up to fit two screwdriver handles or a ratchet drive. For something like a woofer I deliberately used the small handle Torx that limits leverage.

I don't know the exact amount I'm able to exert with the small drive, but it's like tightening brass parts on a carb when assembling an engine, you don't want to overdrive it and ruin the whole assembly.

I believe Dali must have used a locking compound on the screws, keeping the torque uniform over time. I have no proof but this behaves that way in my opinion.

No question that the ratchet handle and reverse motion could break the bond if a driver needed replacing, but I think they have it right where they want it and it was planned that way during assembly.
Interesting thought, I don't doubt you. All materials have a sound and brass is definitely more friendly than steel.

Maybe I should contact the tech guys in Denmark for advise, the same ones I spoke with when I redesigned the crossover.
Tvad,

I kept waiting for you to say the wrench lost grip of the hex driver, slipped and went through a woofer. A real relief to read you lost only time and not parts.

This is the same outcome as my test. I admit I did not even look for brass screws, although that is probably the valuable part of the tweak.
Yep, I don't doubt it. Maybe I'll get the courage to obtain the zillion brass bolts required for my 24 woofers and get to the job one day.