CDP with volume and digital input...Which one?


I am currently searching for this kind of CDP.I've narrowed down to few:

1.Wadia 861 SE, 581, 850 or 860.
2.Resolution Audio Opus 21+GNSC mods
3.DcS P8i
4.One not in this group, but also considered is Njoe Tjoeb 4000+all upgrades.
5.Cambridge Audio 840C (no volume is a minus)
6.Mark Levinson 390S

I have very big and sensitive speakers, full range(Silverline Sinfonia).Also 320B XLS SET monos (15 W/ch).CDP will be connected directly to 320B XLS power amps.
I need dynamics, punch, great bass and a lot of it,also smooth but extended top end and natural midrange...
Listening to heavy metal mostly,also jazz, female vocals.
Has anyone heard any of these players in A/B comparisons?
Which one is the best overall,and which one is a best buy?
Thanks
audiobb

Showing 3 responses by priz

I previously owned the Cary 306/200 and Wadia 861 with the GNS Statement upgrade as well as the APL modded 3910.

I currently own the Accuphase DP 500 (redbook only) and it is a great player. Built like the Wadia (superb) with a very non-digital musical presentation. Great dynamics (micro and macro), and bass. The mids are very neutral and the highs extended but not at all bright.

I play a lot of rock but not heavy metal and also use very sensitive speakers (Zu Audio Definition MK2)

I would certainly include the Accuphase to your list.

Good luck!

Jim
Audiobb,

Unfortunately the Wadia and Cary were used in a different system and room then the Accuphase.

I will say the Wadia is an all around better player than the Cary BUT costs twice as much with the upgrade.

A recent player of mine, the APL 3910 is very dynamic with a more forward presentation than the Accuphase. Both have excellent low end. I think the APL would also be a strong contender but lacks the build quality of the Accuphase or Wadia.

The Accuphase has a more laid back (relaxed if you will) presentation. It is a great musical player with killer detail. It does very well with rock, which is what I mostly listen to, I’m just not positive how it’s presentaion will work with heavy metal. If you desire a more in your face (or upfront) presentation, I would choose the APL, Wadia 861 or 581SE.

Yes, you can run the Accuphase directly to the amp. I’m currently doing so—also with Gabriel Gold interconnects.

Jim
Audiobb, my opinion of the Gabriel Golds is that they are an outstanding cable. Many positives have been written about these cables so I guess a lot of people find them to be a great interconnect.

It’s been too long for me to comment on the Cary 306/200. I owned it several years ago.

My best advice on the Wadias is to call Steve Huntley at Great Northern Sound. He modded my 861 and can answer any Wadia question probably better than anyone.

Jim