CD v. SACD

This was not directed at you Brian, I'm sorry my post came off that way. Yes I know the SCD-1 was used in the review, you would have to live under a rock to not know. My post was regarding the thread and many threads I see here and Audio Asylum(digital drive) and others who site the same thing. I do respect your opinion on this subject, being that you have lived with the players in question. But I honestly do feel that anyone who thinks CD(Redbook) has more to offer than SACD, is just deluding themselves. Just my opinion. Gary.

Natalie,I understand you hate Sony and have an opinion regarding their players, but don't spread false information. No you cannot play the DVDA track on anything other than a DVDA player. You can play any of the lower resolution tracks(Dolby,DTS,etc.), but you cannot play DVDA on anything other than a DVDA player; period. The same holds true for SACD. SACD's(non-hybrid), can only be played on SACD players but hybrids can be played on any SACD player, CD player and DVD player(compatable with Redbook). That puts hybrid SACD's in ten times(at least) the number of players DVDA would be compatable with. Gary.

They want market penetration and poor little me can't afford Accuphase prices. They want the public to find out about SACD and that can only happen if it's affordable. Less than 1% of audiophiles can pay $16,500 for Accuphase hi end, which may or may not be better than an SCD-1(opinions vary). So we can get Sony A quality and pay one fifth of A+. Remember, Sony wants the 99% group desperately, so SACD can succeed. Sony is starting to release more and more hybrids and their production will be up to 25 million disc per year capacity soon. And last time I checked, the Dolby and DTS 5.1 tracks still won't play on my computer, home, or car CD player. I'm not from Canada so I would'nt venture to comment on that situation. But I hope they do go the hybrid way, because it's the only option for success of the format in my opinion. By the way I do own a Toshiba SD9200 and it's one heck of a player. I feel that DVDA betters Redbook by some margin, but does'nt compare to my SCD-1. Gary.