It is not the speakers. They measure pretty flat and much much flatter than a lot of speakers out there. I don't know anything about ARC 150.2 but what price range are you in?
For what it is worth I listened to the 2.4 and 3.7 a few weeks ago with Musical Fidelity A5 integrated and it sounded very good. It was very neutral. It was warm when the recording was warm and bright when the recording was bright. I find Thiel more detailed than most other speakers.... I think people tend to think they are bright because of it. It could also be that people were not give the older Thiels the power they needed to sing.