I just bought 25lbs of vinyl at Ameoba for $98 including three new lps. Only one has excess surface noise and I got two pops in four hours of listening - I've bought new audiophile lps that perform worse than that. You can inspect the cheaper lps at the racks. Ameoba will open the more expensive lps ($10+) at the cashier. This was my first time at Ameoba and I'm very pleased.
