Audiophile Priorities and Recent Topics


I'm increasingly fascinated by the number of threads that have been created lately by OP's who have joined over only the last 2 months with less than 30 posts that all seem related to the importance of wires and tweaks. While I'm not dismissing the notion that everything matters in hifi (including digital cable), it seems that these topics vastly overwhelm thread topics that clearly would have more influence to hifi audio sound such as discussions of the sonic characteristics of various amplifier topologies, the importance of simplifying the signal path, and identifying fantastic speaker/amplifier synergies, etc...

If some unsuspecting newbie were to stumble onto this forum they would likely come away thinking that a fuse or a piece of wire are the most important elements towards obtaining wonderful hifi sound. This is unfortunate. For example, my discovery of listening to a SET circuit years ago paired with speakers possessing a high and flat impedance greatly outshines any joy derived from identifying the finest digital cable produced by man. I'm simply questioning the hifi priorities that this forum seems to be obsessed with lately.

Is it just me?
128x128three_easy_payments

Showing 2 responses by jjss49

fundamentals always matter... speakers that reproduce sound accurately and beautifully, properly set up in a good room, driven by amplification well suited to the speakers, fed by a source that is quiet, pure and true to the media being played

while 'hygiene matters', wires tweaks fuses springs contact enhancers are rounding error, last 1% kinda stuff

like a fresh set of nikes won't let a high school hooper be the next kobe, a new driver won't turn a recreational golfer into another tiger

what is unfortunate to me, about a-gon, is there is the lack of a proper set of ’pinned posts’ or ’stickies’ that many enthusiast forums have, that lay out some foundational information, and well known truths, that newcomers can lean on... not be found here, it is too bad

@three_easy_payments

intended or not, this thread is turning out to be quite a good one with numerous posters entering the discussion with interesting angles and thoughts, and as such, it makes this a better place to spend time at (as opposed to, say a few nitwits who bicker constantly and endlessly about class d amps, and so on, without any useful exchanges of real information)

catching up on the posts, i would make a few furthercomments, in the spirit of lively discussion and hopefully constructive debate

-- my issue with many tweaks is when the cost becomes substantial, then i feel many lose the plot ... yes if you have a system you are veryhappy with, then tweak away to get the last few percent of perceived performance, but some of the tweaks get darned expensive, as cables do, some fuses for a system can add up to a grand or more, so one needs to wonder whether folks buying in are losing the big picture and suspending common sense about relative importance, versus upgrading a systemcomponent rather than tweaks - i remember the shun mook nonsense years ago... yes isolation and tuning of resonances can make a system sound marginally better, but when the stupid wood blocks with little metal tips start to cost thousands, common sense needs to kick that b-s sell job to curb

-- this is a discussion forum attached to a commercial site, and while the forum exists to drive commercial activity, i don’t see the point in talking about who pays what fees or lists gear here vs. on less costly sites as a value judgment on posters who do or don’t... those are personal economic decisions, it is not about what makes this forum good or poor quality (actually what makes this forum good are the wealth of posts and posters, past and present, with something substantive to contribute) ... a lot of us bought and sold lots of gear here, and the sales site changed its fee structure, so some of us took some of our business elsewhere... the change of economic structure of the site has moved sellers much towards dealers than individuals, so what does this have to do with the quality of forum?

-- lastly, to me, without getting too much into arcane car geek stuff, i feel the bmw m3 analogy cited earlier is misplaced... the context is wrong, bmw-cca autocross (leave aside racetrack driving where a factory m3 will melt in 2 laps in an experienced driver’s hands)... firstly, all the improvements made to that posters autocross car are in fact substantial, from brakes to suspension to fluids and so on, he is not changing the battery wiring to the alternator or changing a fuse in the fuse box ... but even so, secondly, go from a ’tweaked’ e46 or e9x m3 to a factory stock 997 gt3 and there is a quantum leap in overall performance (like going from a schiit modius dac to a chord dave or a weiss) - that is the difference between engaging in tweaks to getting an altogether vastly superior piece of gear (speakers, amp, what have you)