ATC SCM40As sound quality at low voume


I recently became very intrigued by the concept of powered speakers with active crossovers, particularly the ATC SCM40A. I read all the reviews I could find and more than one of them mentioned that while they sounded great at loud volume levels, they sounded poor at low volumes. I was surprised. I'm not used to hearing that. I'm not really sure what could explain this. In the grand scheme of things, I'd much rather have a speaker that played loud without strain, but I do often listen to music during "quiet hours" when I shouldn't disturb others in the house. Has anyone experienced the ATCs at lower volumes? Does anyone have an explanation?
blang11

Showing 1 response by jon_5912

shadorne is right - it's about accuracy.  It makes sense if you think about it.  Live music is pretty loud.  Music is written with live performances of real instruments in mind.  Making music that was originally loud sound good at low volumes requires the response to be modified to compensate.  This modification only works at low volumes, though.  Increase the volume to close to realistic levels and it sounds wrong again.

The solution, in my opinion, is to build a system that is as accurate as possible at realistic volume and then use equalization to modify it when you want something other than accuracy.  If you never want to listen at anything close to a realistic volume then speakers that are optimized for low volume listening are fine.