Article: "Spin Me Round: Why Vinyl is Better Than Digital"


Article: "Spin Me Round: Why Vinyl is Better Than Digital"

I am sharing this for those with an interest. I no longer have vinyl, but I find the issues involved in the debates to be interesting. This piece raises interesting issues and relates them to philosophy, which I know is not everyone's bag. So, you've been warned. I think the philosophical ideas here are pretty well explained -- this is not a journal article. I'm not advocating these ideas, and am not staked in the issues -- so I won't be debating things here. But it's fodder for anyone with an interest, I think. So, discuss away!

https://aestheticsforbirds.com/2019/11/25/spin-me-round-why-vinyl-is-better-than-digital/amp/?fbclid...
hilde45

Showing 3 responses by audio2design

It is unquestionable that MQA alters the sound, and that includes in the audio band. It forces a filter type on the DAC chain that many find unnatural, but music dependent could be beneficial (to some).

They start with the ignorant notion that "pre-ringing" is bad. If you know what "pre-ringing" is, you will know what this is not a sound theory, and that square waves don't happen in audio.  Then they make the bold almost univeral claim that audio is impacted by a ton of 20KHz bessel filters are stacked in a series.  Well maybe that was a bit common 30+ years ago, but not recently, and even then that really was not true.  So they claim their filter recreates the leading edge of transients. Only problem is, once the information is gone, it is gone. Unless you know exactly the signal chain that arrived at that signal, you can't reverse it. How do you know intentional equalization versus unintentional band limiting?  And at the end of it all, the engineers working on the recording are equalizing anyway for the end result.
bluemoodriver40 posts01-22-2021 1:22pmSo, you can make a digital recording of what comes out of the phono stage, and then play that recording through the same system.  If the ear can’t tell the difference then it would seem that the digital format can accurately capture and reproduce the sounds produced upstream of the phono out.
Is that true?

If that is true, then the digital capture can be compared to the digital master used to make the vinyl in the first place. Now you can make a filter to put in downstream of your digital source.
Someone must have tried this already?  With any success?


It is true.

There are a bunch of functions that would need to be incorporate including mixing channels to increase crosstalk, adding noise that has to also include the compression/decompression from RIA, etc.  Lots of people have played with this,


If you want the full analog chain equivalent there are plug-ins that simulate specific tape machines.
My response to you would be not to post such silly things. DACs output analog signals, not bits and bytes