This is one of the interesting threads that has attracted me to this place. Please correct me if I am misunderstanding you, but I see them as attempting to explore what it is we like about listening to music - the visceral experience of it. I was trying to get at the same thing from a different angle with a thread I started recently on warm up. Others that I would put in the same category are those on the sound of vinyl and altered states of consciousness. I think I’ve already quoted Frank Zappa, who said something along the lines of “writing about music is like dancing about architecture.” It’s still a worthy exercise, even though no one has quite nailed it yet.