Anyone try center backs this way???????........


I was at a mid/hi-fi store not too long ago and the owner mentioned one of his customers does this with his center backs in a 7.1 setup...\

The center backs are monitors with front ports , they are placed on their backs' against wall on floor firing up to the ceiling, He tells me this makes the whole wall open up for surround because of reflections, now my B&W Dipoles are mounted on the wall so I cant and wont try this but has anyone done this?...I figured it was interesting enough to post.
chadnliz
I've done this in a 5.1 setup, and it is nice with non-directional sounds (rain, traffic etc.), but it sounds pretty weird with voices, so I changed it back.
Chadnliz,

When you say center backs, did you mean two rear channel speakers spread apart on the back wall? I hope they don't have the two speakers placed together at the center of the rear wall as rear speakers should be spaced about 150 degrees from the listening position (sides are at 90 deg). Reasons are avoiding possible back to front reversals, and spearding the rear surround information across the back. Rears are not intended to be a point source.

I have heard of arrangements like you mentioned when there was less than adequate space behind the listening area to properly place the rear speakers; e.g., listening position is a couch placed almost against the back wall. Unless the room layout has an unusual situation like that, I think you would be better off placing the rear speakers in a normal front facing direction (but spread apart).

Bruce
If you are using cheap receiver and cheap speakers this may (and does in some rooms) work very well. It gives a more diffuse soundfield in the rear if you are sitting in close proximity to the surround speakers.

For good mid-fi or high-end components this is likely less than ideal. The reflected sound from walls is altered by the wall surface. If you are depending on this reflected sound for the entire volume of information from the speaker (rather than only some of the information as in bi/mono-pole or electrostat)you are never going to hear the details that these more resolving speakers are capable of. However "monitors" are not always going to give you wide dispersion which is what you want in a surround.

Flip-side is that if the room sucks try anything you can to create the illusion of good sound regardless of equipment quality.

Yes, I guess it would be something in the order of... Spice.
Years ago, in a small living room, I had the rear surround speakers up high, but facing toward the ceiling. This was with a DPL setup, but it sounded quite nice.
Ok, all my input is hearsay--Generally the room is the weakest part of your system. I would say this may add some 'spice'--but not accurate 'spice'---33 years ago I had Bose901s and hung them on lamp chain. (High up and near each corner)That means 16 drivers facing the wall. I could lay down on the floor and listen to the music coming from beind me. It was a fun novelty. aka spice.
I did it once when I did not have appropriate stands. If you're going for the rear ambiance sort of thing, it works. I would tend not to want to do this for multichannel hirez audio, where fidelity is more important.