An $1100 home theater PC will look a lot better than a $10000 DVD player/video scaler combo.
You are rolling the DVD player and scaler into one unit, but are not using it for an audio pre-amp. The HTPC isn't going to top a low end stereo receiver in that category, but it is pretty tough to beat for DVD playback. With an SDI modified DVD player and an H3D card, you will probably be beating anything short of a Teranex.
A $2000 reference VHS deck won't look as good as a $400 DVD player. Likewise, a $2000 reference DVD player won't look as good as a much cheaper HTPC. It isn't even close. Go to AVS forum and find somebody in your area who has one and ask if you can come over and see it. Once you do, you will understand.
You are rolling the DVD player and scaler into one unit, but are not using it for an audio pre-amp. The HTPC isn't going to top a low end stereo receiver in that category, but it is pretty tough to beat for DVD playback. With an SDI modified DVD player and an H3D card, you will probably be beating anything short of a Teranex.
A $2000 reference VHS deck won't look as good as a $400 DVD player. Likewise, a $2000 reference DVD player won't look as good as a much cheaper HTPC. It isn't even close. Go to AVS forum and find somebody in your area who has one and ask if you can come over and see it. Once you do, you will understand.