Before you invest big bucks, why don't you buy a used Well Tempered turntable and arm, find a decent cartridge, and have some fun. After playing with this setup you can decide if it provides a level of listening pleasure that has been missing from your digital system.
If in the end you are not drawn in to the world of analog, you can sell the gear for about what you paid.
Without the pressure of a big investment, you may find the initial fun of analog becomes addictive and will eventually replace a portion of your music library.
If in the end you are not drawn in to the world of analog, you can sell the gear for about what you paid.
Without the pressure of a big investment, you may find the initial fun of analog becomes addictive and will eventually replace a portion of your music library.