All things Must Pass- High Rez Download SQ ?


All things Must Pass by George Harrison- High Rez Download.

Can anyone comment as to the sound quality of the High Rez 24/96 download ?
ozzy

Showing 6 responses by vhiner

Cerrot,

Great news! Can you also post this to the "What High Res Releases Are Worth Buying?" thread?
Ozzy, I haven't heard the hi-Rez version but I'm as curious as you are. I wish there were a reputable and dependable review site for "hi-Rez" downloads. I'm sure you've also discovered that just because it's 24/96 doesn't mean it's gonna sound any better than Redbook.
I wish Stereophile and Absolute Sound would start a running data base of what's worth owning in Hi Rez and what is not. For example, I defy HD tracks to demonstrate that the 24/96 version of Raising Sand that they continue to sell is superior to the Redbook CD. The hi-rez version may be different, but it is not superior. HD Tracks frequently leaves out information about who has mastered a given dowload, whether the source has merely been up sampled,, etc. There is also a real question as to whether most of us can actually hear the difference between 96, 172 and 196. Perhaps if really great music by the best performers were recorded by the best engineers and mastered by the top masterers, we could determine this. So far, most of the hi Rez music out there is mediocre or has been produced by self appointed audiophile experts. Ever noticed how most "audiophile" label music sucks? "Exotic Dances" isn't my idea of a great way to sell a new medium. I'm still waiting to be impressed by Hi Rez. It ain't as good as high definition video.....yet.
Ozzy,

All Things Must Pass is a great work and I hope whoever did the hi-Rez release knew what he or she was doing. However, there just isn't the quality control with downloads that there is with physical discs. It's harder to make excuses or blame someone else's computer set up when the disc comes with a company's label on it. Anybody can post a download.

I do agree with your assessment of the Sticky Fingers release. I think Bob Ludwig was in charge of the hi-Rez remastering of that, if memory serves. Again, we really need a vetted list of hi-Rez releases that have been directly compared to the Red Book.