Acoustic Sound Treatment


I have installed 4 DIY 4'x 30'' Jon Risch's sound panels.

Three went on the back wall covering four French doors.
The other went on a side wall at the first reflection point. The other side is a open wall.

The result I got is almost unbelievable. I never dreamed that these panels would change the sound so much for the better!

The music was all over the place before the panels. Now the soundstage is where it belongs and the sound is more focused. LP's that I thought were not recorded well are indeed right sounding.

This audio hobby done right must hit on all cylinders to reach the ultimate end. One of them is sound treatment. We can disagree on cables etc. but you have to be BD&D not to hear a difference in a properly treated room.

The back wall ceiling starts on a upward climb to 22'.

Would two ceiling corner panels help out to further treat my room?
glory

Showing 3 responses by mrjstark

Another believer. Congrats and welcome to the club.
As for the corners. I am not sure if you meant corner bass traps or small corner peaces called " corner-busters ", which are triangular panels that mount into the ceiling corners of a listening room to trap the sound that would otherwise echo back into the room. These are important treatment areas since sound eventually finds it’s way into the corners of a room. Yes they help, especially improving speech clarity and in most cases eliminate megaphone effect. If you are not sure if they are right for you, get it from the place with generous return policy.
Good luck & happy listening
Mariusz Stark.
Acoustical design must take into consideration that in addition to physiological peculiarities of the ear, hearing is complicated by psychological peculiarities. For example, sounds that are unfamiliar seem unnatural. Sound produced in an ordinary room is somewhat modified by reverberations due to reflections from walls and furniture; for this reason, a broadcasting studio should have a normal degree of reverberation to ensure natural reproduction of sound. For best acoustic qualities, rooms are designed to produce sufficient reflections for naturalness, without introducing excessive reverberation at any frequency, without echoing certain frequencies unnaturally, and without producing undesirable interference effects or distortion.
The time required for a sound to diminish to one-millionth of its original intensity is called reverberation time. An appreciable reverberation time improves acoustical effect, especially for music; a loud sound should still be barely audible for one to two seconds after the sound has stopped in an auditorium. In a private home a shorter but still discernible reverberation time is desirable.
For modifying the reverberations, you have a choice of two types of materials, sound-absorbent and sound-reflecting, to coat the surfaces of ceilings, walls, and floors. Soft materials such as cork and felt absorb most of the sound that strikes them, although they may reflect some of the low-frequency sounds. Hard materials such as stone and metals reflect most of the sound that strikes them.
In most cases, the acoustics of a room will be satisfactory if a proper balance between sound-absorbing and sound-reflecting materials is created. Troublesome echoes may frequently occur in a room that otherwise has a proper overall reverberation time if the ceiling or a wall is concave in shape and is highly reflecting; in such cases, sound may be focused at a particular point, making the acoustics bad at that point in the room. Similarly, a narrow corridor between parallel reflecting walls may trap sound by repeated reflection and cause troublesome echoes, even though the overall absorption is sufficient. Attention must also be given to the elimination of interference. Such interference arises from the difference in the distances traversed by the direct and the reflected sound and produces so-called dead spots, in which certain ranges of frequency are canceled out.
Another aspect of room acoustics is insulation from unwanted sound.

The Funk & Wagnalls New Encyclopedia are licensed from K-III Reference Corporation. ©1994-96 K-III Reference Corporation. Posted without permission for educational purposes only.
M.S
First - proper speakers placement. You should start there.
First reflection points next.
Now... there are 2 schools of "live end - dead end".
1.Live front end - dead back end.
2.Dead front end - live back end.
It is hard for me to recommend which road should you choose, since everybody have a different opinion on this subject. Second I don't want somebody to think that I am an expert on that matter, because I am NOT. What I do have is a lot off experience in set-ups in problematic rooms and my own experimentation and measurements. And NO, I am not a dealer or installer. What I do , I do for my friends and fellow audiophiles. I never charge a stinking penny and I do it for pure satisfaction.
In my own room I implemented treatments according to my rooms particular problems. All room are more or less different from each other and that makes it more difficult to recommend one solution over the other.
My own preferences is semi-dead front end and live- diffused back end with just a little absorbing.
Trick is to not to over treat you listening room. Believe it or not but some reflections are beneficial and you don't want to kill all of them. Ceiling treatment and bass tweaking is another matter maybe for another thread.
Mariusz Stark