A question concerning ethics


Should business professionals related to the audio field be required to register as such when joining Audiogon or making public posts ? I am talking about those that are involved with manufacturing / marketing / advertising / wholesaling / retailing, etc... audio gear or audio related accessories. After all, if someone is "raving" or "bad-mouthing" a product or product line, i want to know if they are simply a "joe average" end user / consumer or if they have something to gain by promoting or slagging specific products. Would this be out of line in your opinion ?

Obviously, this would be done on the honor system since anybody can make comments with total anonymity and thicken their wallets or take pot-shots at their competition. The fact that MANY that post here have made their affiliations clear only adds credibility to their posts since they were willing to be up-front and honest to begin with. Those that "string along the crowd" can only expect complete distrust once they are found out. I am not going to name names here, but i think that a few of the guilty parties will know who i'm talking about. Sean
>
sean

Showing 2 responses by brulee

Sean, having dealt with Jtinn in the past and will again in the future if the need is there I hope you did your homework on Jtinn. I contacted Jtinn about the Tenor amps about two months ago and he told me in he was a dealer for them. He was not trying to hide that information. Maybe he went about this in a way that doesn't please you but I don't think for a minute that he was trying to deceive anyone. He was upfront with me and that is all I can ask of a person. To name names of parties who are trying to deceive others I am all for but I would have to know this for a fact. Do you know for a fact that Jtinn was being deceitful? To ruin a good mans reputation without facts is as unethical as one can be. I have no doubt that your intentions are honorable and that you are trying to do the right thing for us Audiogon members but unless you know something I don't, I can't help but think you may have dropped the ball on this one. I can only relate my experience with Jtinn and they have been honorable.
I agree with Tomthompson point of view. If you are new to this site it won't take long to figure out the good guys from the bad. If you buy on hype then you unfortunatly get what you deserve. I also agree with Cornfedboy who has been as good a watchdog as he is a poster. Sneaking in the back door is IMO unethical. Sean, if you have proof of this going on then wouldn't it be ethical to point out the culprit or culprits? Once a manufactuer lets members know who he or she is they can be very good contributers. I have found Ken Lyons of Neuance to be one of Audiogon's most respected and knowledgable posters. He is just one example as there are many more. Sean, you say you are not going to name names. I can understand why you would not but if you no for a fact that this is going on, Wouldn't it be benificial for all members to name names?