2-Way 3-Way Debate


I am fairly new here and would imagine that this debate has taken place previously. Sorry if I don't have time to scroll back through all the speaker topics but can a 2- way spkr really provide the definition of a 3-way? If the bass/ mid driver is 6" or 7", how can it handle the upper mids?

Currently there is a pair of 2-way Castle Acoustics with front port for sale in the monitors section. I am assuming that the front port does more than just relieve internal pressure and it actually provides additional bass sound, leaving the bass/ mid driver a little less congested. What about bi-amping with a 2-way compared with a 3-way?

i would imagine that I would actually have to hear the Castles and compare them to my 3-way JBL G300's( which i can find no probs with). My amp is a Denon DRA-395( with SLDC). The amp does not have bi-amp capability but the Castles do although I understand that a cable can be fitted to my amp solving that prob.

Any thoughts are appreciated. roscoe

Has Audiogon ever considered implementing a 30 or 60 day trial section where members could sell spkrs conditionally?
roscoe50

Showing 1 response by ngjockey

Limiting the conversation to conventional dynamic drivers and not horns...

Let's say the tweeter, as typically, goes down to 1.5 to 2KHz. In a 2-way, that means the woofer has to cover up to that. Any woofer, any size, designed to accommodate that wide range will be compromised for upper midrange or low bass. More the latter. Physics, mass, etc...

Then, you get into power handling, which is also driver and frequency dependant. End result will be that a 3-way is more likely of stronger dynamics.

In a 3-way, you also get to raise the tweeter crossover point, which can be very useful, particularly for some ribbon types. Our ears are most sensitive and discerning in the vocal range, although that exact frequency range is still debateable.

Every crossover has a phase shift but so does the driver, over a wider range. The advantage of 2-ways is not only the simpler design but the higher crossover uses smaller inductors and capacitors.

It comes down to how you listen. A personal choice. Nice to have a choice.