Ng... thanks for the phase coherence article. The article seems to be based on scientific controlled studies and tests. Rather than paraphrase the conclusions, I copied them here:
"So what conclusions regarding the audibility of phase distortion can we draw from the all of the above?
'Given the data provided by the above cited references we can conclude that phase distortion is indeed audible, though generally speaking, only very subtly so and only under certain specific test conditions and perception circumstances.
'The degree of subtly depends upon the nature of the test signal, the dB SPL level at which the signal is perceived, the acoustic environment in which the signal was recorded and/or played back as well as the Q & fo of any filter networks in the signal stream. Certain combinations of conditions can render it utterly inaudible.
'Room acoustics further masks whatever cues that the hearing process may depend upon to detect the presence of phase distortion."
And here's my personal bottom line. Phase coherence is just one of many variables that is taken into account when designing a speaker system ... and there are many. As many folks have said, trust your ears and audition as many speakers as you can. But ... if I was asked to buy speakers based on their phase coherence characteristics as a stand-alone factor, I personally would not.
Thanks again Ng.... Good article. It puts the issue into context.
Bruce
"So what conclusions regarding the audibility of phase distortion can we draw from the all of the above?
'Given the data provided by the above cited references we can conclude that phase distortion is indeed audible, though generally speaking, only very subtly so and only under certain specific test conditions and perception circumstances.
'The degree of subtly depends upon the nature of the test signal, the dB SPL level at which the signal is perceived, the acoustic environment in which the signal was recorded and/or played back as well as the Q & fo of any filter networks in the signal stream. Certain combinations of conditions can render it utterly inaudible.
'Room acoustics further masks whatever cues that the hearing process may depend upon to detect the presence of phase distortion."
And here's my personal bottom line. Phase coherence is just one of many variables that is taken into account when designing a speaker system ... and there are many. As many folks have said, trust your ears and audition as many speakers as you can. But ... if I was asked to buy speakers based on their phase coherence characteristics as a stand-alone factor, I personally would not.
Thanks again Ng.... Good article. It puts the issue into context.
Bruce