Members without scruples- a continuation


This is a continuation of a discussion started by Sagger on 01/11/02:
Regarding Audiogon's feedback policy, how is a potential buyer going to research a seller's (or vice versa)feedback rating to determine its validity? The very real possibility exists that an unscrupulous person could create multiple accounts, then leave positive feedback for a main account. Once that positive feedback is established in the main account, the person could use that account to hurt other members.
greatpooba
I agree that there would be value added in being able to view another member's transaction history. I've built a couple of systems from Audiogon transactions as a buyer and have spent big chuncks of money in doing so. More recently, I've bought a lot of CD's and SACD's in small transactions (in some cases $10 or less) that rate equally in the feedback system with large dollar purchases ($4k was my biggest). The Ebay system allows one to delve further into the details of transactions, which is helpful in evaluatng members without much feedback.
I would say that on Ebay about 15% of the sellers are either non-professional or thieves. I have seen many auctions go down, most good, some not so good. Of course on Ebay, you have a lot of pawn shops listing, who not have a clue about their stuff. A problem the Ebay system however, is that people are afraid to bash sellers because the feedback is usually sent back at them!

I am a big fan of TALKING personally, with anyone with whom I am looking at a potential large purchase. GOOD LUCK.
Perhaps I am naive, but I most people to be honest.
Here's a tip on how to post negative feedback on Ebay without repercussions:
Auction feedback can be posted up to 90 days after the close of an auction. If you were screwed by the seller and want to post negative feedback, but fear an unwarranted backlash, then just sit tight for the 90 days. About 5 minutes before the deadline runs out, post your negative feedback. By the time the seller notices it, it's too late to post any back. Works like a charm.
Octopus, nice "reverse snipe" move wtth your negative feedback strategy on Ebay! I love it...

In my post above, I mentioned the lack of value weighting of the Audiogon feedback system (i.e., there is no way to differentiate a $10 transaction from at $4K transaction). Ironically, as I logged into my A'gon account tonight, I discovered that I've received 4 identical positive feedback posts for the purchase of 4 CD's listed for $9.99 each, which I paid for in one effortless PayPal transfer. No offense to the seller in question, who in fairness did list each CD in a seperate ad and was only trying to be nice... but would Audiogon, upon request, remove positive feedback that a member has received that he/she does not feel was warranted? Similarly, can a member who has inadvertantly posted feedback twice for the same transaction recall his/her message? The A'gon feedback rules do not seem to allow for such circumstances, but perhaps someone knows better than I.