Avalon Isis or Sonus Faber Liliam


Has anyone had the opportunity to A B the above 2 speakers? Any feed back in regard to either one will be appreciated.

128x128samgar2
Thanks for your reply.

Presently I have a pair of Avalon Isis and would like to possibly make a change to another manufacturer as I have had them for 4 years. I might be ready for a change. I have had experience with Sonus Faber and wonder if their larger speakers sound as good as the current Avalon. I mostly listen to jazz and want good mid-range with tight bass response, no boom. Sound should be natural and non- fatiguing.

Judging by your brief description alone, I would say stick to the Isis. The SF would probably be slightly more pronounced in the high frequencies and, while quick & dynamic enough, they would not be appreciably more so than your Isis; nor would the bass frequencies be improved (although SF offer a bass amplitude control button) - maybe a tad deeper.
What may be more attractive is the SF mid-range. The SF sounds silky whereas the Isis sounds accurate (that ceramic mid...); simply put, a badly recorded violin will be sonic purgatory on the Isis but only slight torture on the SF.
Overall, and considering you listen to jazz -- i.e. you need to reproduce dynamics and nuances full-range -- you are OK as is.
If you like fast, coherent & musical sounding speakers, i'd try to get an audition of the new Magico M3's.
Magico M3 a bargin at 75k i heard them they were great still love my Q3s.