2. amps-preamps
  3. 1014962180

Which direction would you go?

I have spent the last ten years living with a system that is to my ears unlistenable. I was sucked in by the stereophile recommended components list, and bought based on cost and ratings, rather than common sense and proper auditions. I ended up with the following: B&W 802 Matrix II's, a Threshold S350e amp, a Krell KBL preamp, and a front end comprised of a Theta pro Gen II and Data Mk II. As you might well imagine, I have endured bright, harsh sound in three different homes over the years. I tried room tunes (any buyers?) all manner of cables (I presently own Cardas Cross bi-wire) a CJ premier 10 pre-amp (not enough of a difference to justify the switch) and Cal audio front end. In frustration, I have sold the Krell, and the Threshold, and have active listings for the B&W and Cardas, and plans to sell the Theta as soon as possible. I listen mostly to small scale instrumental and female vocals from various genres. I enjoy Linda Ronstadt, Sara K, Rickie Lee Jones, Allison Krauss, Annie Lennox, Dixie Chicks, Etta James, Karen Carpenter, Joe Sample, Miles, Ronnie Earl, Govi, Willie and Lobo, Lyle Lovett, James Taylor, and so much more. I have front row center seats for the NY Philharmonic for the last fifteen years and have seen more concerts than I could name. I was set on the idea of downsizing to a home theater setup, Integra receiver and DVD/CD with Definitive Technology pro 100 speaker system or maybe the NHT Super Series SB3. They seem to have OK sound on both music and movies, but I wonder if the trade-off is too great since 98% of the time I will be listening to music with only an occasional music video or movie. I am quite certain I have never heard my B&W's perform the way they should, but am not certain I wish to invest more money chasing the Holy Grail. (Also tried Bryston 4B). I have reviewed threads here and contemplated trying the Classe gear. I have also thought about selling the B&W's and buying a speaker with a silk dome tweeter or a propensity toward warmth. (Mission, Soliloquy, JM Labs, Vandersteen) My room is a LIVING room and dining room L shape, (20 x13 living attached to 14 x12 dining) and it is lively with 11' acoustical ceiling. In any event, I would like to avail myself of the multi-channel options while focusing on two channel performance. I keep my speakers on the long wall and listen near-field. I do not believe electrostats are an option for me due to size, placement, and WAF issues. Please let me know your thoughts, and be gentle as this is my first post here on Agon.
mike7142
smw30yahoocom
154 posts
 
Check out Legend Audio Design. They have an integrated for $3000 which sounds fabulous. I have the triode monoblocks, but they are around $5500. Legend products are very detailed and dynamic, but very enjoyable to listen to for hours. Of course, much of what you hear will be attributed to other parts of your system - speakers, wires, room size and set up. I would definitely go with tubes in your case, they are much easier to listen to for long periods of time. Also check out Rogue, they have great products for the price. McIntosh is also easy on the ears, at least the tube products.
Ag insider logo xs@2x
drubin
3,274 posts
 
Mike, great post, first of all. I think we can all relate.

Have you heard a system you really loved? At someone's home or at a dealer's or perhaps the Home Entertainment Show (coming up end of May in NYC)? You might think about finding an entire system you like the sound of, then duplicating it, or doing so selectively. My feeling is that relacing a com-ponent here and there in your current set-up may get you where you want to be, but it's hit-or-miss. A top-down, system approach may be more effective. Synergy is everything.
ttrulis
8 posts
 
Hey Mike,
I had the same problem with B&W.
Had the 805 Nautilus, the sound was so bright, I had to put on sun-screen!
I tried them with all manner of solid state and mos-fet integrated amps, including such non-bright amps as the Rega Mira.
Also tried the Electrocompaniet ECI 3, The Bryston, The Arcam A85, and Plinius 8100.
Changed my cd player from the Arcam 72 to the Rega Planet 2000. Changed ALL my cables and still the B&W's remained way too hot. Even with my Linn turntable, those 805's burned the walls!
My dealer suggested a sub woofer to help compensate for the harshness. I did not take his advice because it did not address the basic problem of those metal dome tweeters.
After about 4 months, I sold them and bought Dynaudios 72's.
They retail for about $800 less and after break in, they absolutely smoke the B&W's.
Great bass and fullness, just as detailed as the B&W's but much more listenable and realistic. My suggestion, audition a pair of Dyn's. They will be music to your ears.
The Plinius 8100 is a great integrated. Powerful, detailed, explosive, and with the Dyns pretty smooth.
Match carfully with cable. I noticed the power cables made a big difference.
I had an AC master coupler from Synergistic, this just made the problem worse.
I now am cabled through-out with Transparent, altho the VDH sounded excellent too!.

Hope this helps. Good luck.
brulee
564 posts
 
Pops has a great system. I don't remember what Thiels he owns. I heard in all places, a dealers showroom the Theils 3.something with all Classe equipment except for an Audio Aero CDP that the person brought along to audition the Thiels. I was very impressed. Accurate yet very musical and involving. If a warmer sound is more to your liking, try Vanderseen 3s. Keep looking. There are a lot of good speakers in your price range. You have just been told about 3 of them. If you should get 10 more responses, you will probably get 10 different opinions.
Best in your quest for the best in your budget.
sean
6,231 posts
 
You mention trying other amp / preamp combo's, different digital front ends, tons of different cables, etc... so that kind of rules those out as the source of "bleeding ear syndrome". As such, you are left with your speakers as the logical source of your problems. Regardless of all of the other combo's that you tried, it was the one mainstay in the system ( other than the brightness ).

While you might be able to find a combo of gear that will tame the characteristics about them that you don't like, my guess is that you would end up in the same situation that you are already in. That is, IF you build a new system around them. This is not to say that B&W's are bright or "bad" speakers, only that they are not to your personal taste.

I would look at the size of your room, the volume levels and tonal balance that you want to achieve and then look at speakers with those factors in mind. Once you've found something that interests you, you'll know about how much power you'll need to look for and can start working backwards from there.

This is not to say that i think that the speakers are more important than all of the other links in the chain, but they can be the most influential. I say this based on various power demands, how they load and react with the room, dispersion characteristics, etc.. All of other products simply process and pass along what electrical signal is already there. Speakers convert that electrical signal to a mechanical signal and as such, have twice as many variables to deal with.

I would look for something that was relatively efficient ( 89+ db's or so) a relatively easy ( non-reactive ) load to drive, medium to high impedance ( 6 - 10 ohms ) and something that will work ( in terms of placement and your listening position ) within your requirements. This will make amplifier selection quite a bit easier and allow you to concentrate on a high quality source and minimizing losses in the preamp.

Just a thought and hope you don't find it out of line. Sean
>
More to discover