PC based system, questions and clarifications...

Well, let’s do a cost analysis of SB verses a computer rig.

SB3:
SB3 $300 (goes on sale every few weeks for $250)
Bolder Cables enthusiast analog mod $550 (includes shipping)
Elpac power supply (new) $123
Bolder Cables Elpac mod $125
Nokia N770 webpad $130
Signal cable 3' analog2 with bullet plugs $87
500GB eternal USB/eSATA backup drive $120
Total Cost - $1435 (all prices include shipping)

I put my friend into the same rig minus the Nokia and a 250GB HD about two weeks ago. His total cost was about $1250. His system consists of Anthem AVM2/Anthem 5 channel amp and VSA 4jr's. He was blown away by the sound even before the break in. He got so excited; he stayed up all night ripping CD's.

Computer Rig:
Mac mini to put in audio rack w/wireless keyboard $750
Buffalo 1TB Terrastation with raid $600
USB dac Benchmark $1275 Bel Canto DAC3 $2500 Wavelength Brick $1750
Signal cable 3' analog2 with bullet plugs $87
Misc cable - USB, Ethernet $50
Total Cost $2762 - $3987

I configured the computer rig to use the TV as a monitor. I'm assuming that this is going into a HT rig. If not, you will need to add a monitor. I know that some people use a laptop with a long USB cable running to the USB DAC in the audio rack. If you go this way, then drop the Apple mini and substitute a laptop. The mini has a neat little remote that will allow you to control playback from your listening chair.

I don't understand why you want a NAS with a usb port. You cannot plug a USB DAC into a NAS. It can only be plugged into a computer. Why do you want the NAS in the listening room? Hang it off of a wireless router in another room so you don't have to hear it.

I'm not saying one is better than the other. It just depends on what you’re trying to accomplish and how involved you want to get. If you don't want to get involved in mods, then just buy the Transporter, plug it in and away you go. The most important thing to remember is to backup all your music. I've had to re-rip my entire collection 3 times. Now I have two backup drives and I backup once a month.

I can't take a picture of my nokia right know because I just sent my SB2 back for an upgrade. Yes, I know I'm spending more on mods, but I like the convenience of having all of my collection on a HD; I will never go back to a standalone cd player.

BTW, my office system, which also runs the slim server software, consists of a PS Audio Digital Link III DAC driving a pair of Red Dragon Monos. Speakers consist of ERA Design4's and a custom sub based on the Pinnacle subcompact six. I don't use the USB connection on the DAC; I prefer using the coax digital out from my PC. Playback software is WMP 11.

While I like the SB I do not like it’s interface... small>

I am glad I am not alone - I was considering using the Squeezebox as well,
but could not stand the interface (either the web-based one or the little
display). One of the main reasons I would not consider it.

I like the Mac Mini as the center of the entertainment system and prefer the
Front Row interface (maybe just personal taste). The ultimate goal was to
replace my CDP (which it did) as well as the DVD player and a second
Windows PC that is used for watching Cricket.

I have both the Benchmark USB DAC 1 and the Wavelength Brick - which one
works better depends very much on the rest of the system. The Brick's
strengths lie in the midrange and resolution of fine details, but the bass is
very much on the soft side. The Benchmark has much tighter, fuller, tuneful
bass and more apparent top end resolution, althought it doesn't quite recover
the texture and resonances of instruments as well as the Brick. The
Benchmark has a more lively and direct presentation, the Brick more laid back
and flowing.

Thanks Prpixel for your comments. I already own a SB3. While I like the convenience of being able to select music from my hard drive (I have only ripped about 15 CD’s) I am not that impressed with the sound quality (playing FLAC files, ethernet connection not wireless) of playback. It certainly is not better than my CD player. My SB has not been modified except I added a high quality linear PS. I would certainly like to compare a modified SB with a stock unit before I sent mine in. Even so most people have stated that a computer based sound system using a high end USB DAC beats a SB. At the RMAF show last weekend I heard an awesome computer based system JA of Stereophile had a seminar comparing mp3, 16/44.1 and 24/88.2. He was playing his files thru a Bel Canto Dac3. The rest of the electronics were Conrad Johnson but the speakers were only a $2,000 pr Avalon’s.

I will probably be using a laptop (either a iBook G4 or a MS Vista based notebook). There is a neat little software program ($23) that I can put on my bluetooth wireless PDA that will allow me to remotely control my laptop if needed. I will investigate the mini. All of this equipment will be in my dedicated 2 channel system. The HT is in another room.

I was only looking for a USB/firewire/ethernet interface incase I decided to go the MS Vista route instead of the iBook G4. No big deal as I will most likely get the Ethernet version, that way it is a standalone unit that can be in another room.

Wow, ripped your CD’s 3 times! What happened? I have used PC’s (before hard drives) and I have only had one drive fail on me. Initially I was only thinking of getting a single 1TM drive (about $300) and save some money, maybe not now….

I see that you have a PS Audio Digital Link III DAC. What do you think of it? Did you compare it to any other DAC’s? To the SB?

Thanks again for your input.

Restock: I am sorry but I am Apple dumb. I have been an intel/MS user since the days of DOS. What is “Front Row” interface? Thank you for your input/comparison of the DAC’s. The Wavelength Brick was one of my considerations as well. I have to see if they have a 30 trial like Benchmark does. What file format did you use?

Thanks

Alan49,

The stock SB3 is not that great. It's good enough for casual listening or background music. Most people think that you can just replace the switching power supply with a linear power supply. The problem is that the power section inside the SB3 needs to be modified in order to get the full benefit. I've heard an SB3 with a standard Elpac linear power supply. It is a slight improvement over the stock unit. The modded Elpac is much better.

Apple front row is a simple interface and remote that lets you control your Mac from your listening chair. It's very similar to MS Windows Media center.

The reason I had to rip three times is that my first HD died. So, I re-ripped, but forgot to turn off copy protection, and could not access my collection from slimserver. So, deleted everything and started over for the third time. It takes me about a month to rip everything. My collection now resides on three 750GB drives: one in the machine and two backups. If you’re using lossless, then figure on about 4 CD per GB. So, 1TB will give you enough room for about 4000 CD's.

I have a few USB DACs around the house: MHTD Labs Paradisea Tube DAC, MHTD Constantine and a PS audio Digilink III. In addition, I've owned the Firestone FUBARII w/Supplier power supply and Perreaux SXD2 DAC. I've also auditioned the Bel Canto Dac3 in my office system. The Fubar was my first USB DAC and I liked it a lot. I picked up the Perreaux to replace it, but liked the Fuber better, so I sold it hear. The Paradisea gives up a little detail for smoothness over the Constantine; I prefer the Constantine. I use the Paradisea in my wife’s computer system which consists of a custom Sub with a three channel plate amp driving a small pair of Canton CD10's. Here source is a Gateway Vista laptop and playback is through Softsqueeze, which gives her access to my entire library. The Bel Canto was good, but I could not justify the price so I did not purchase one (borrowed from friend).

I vacillate between the Constantine and the PS audio DACS. Some days I like the PS audio, some days I prefer the Constantine. I guess it just depends on the mood I'm in. One final note, I use the coax digital in on both DACS. I prefer the sound of the coax digital over the USB input. This might be a function of the USB input or it could be my computer. I find that the USB input lacks a little PRAT. Gordon at Wavelength has developed a USB input receiver for his DACs that are suppose to eliminate this problem, but I've never heard any of this DACs.

While I've never tried any of these DACS in the big rig I have tried the SB in the office system. The modded SB is better than all the USB DACs. The problem I have with using the SB in the Office rig is that I occasionally play a game and you can't get Windows audio/game audio over the SB.

I'm not going to beat the SB drum anymore. It's your ears, your money and your decision. Ultimately, it's up to you to decide. Most modded equipment is a poor investment because of lower resale values.

I just wanted to give you a little background on myself. I've been involved in audio and the industry for over 25 years. I'm a frustrated musician: piano, acoustic guitar and flute. The flute was a requirement for 4th grade music class and I've stuck with it and taken professional lessons. Hey, it's easy to carry around. Every once in a while I take it out and do my Ian Anderson impression. I'm a member of the Philadelphia Orchestra and go to concerts about once or twice a month. I also attend any of the pre-concert lectures and I really enjoy the learning concerts. I have taken many courses on music and music appreciation. I have very acute hearing. I was legally blind for many years. Now here's that part that's going to get me in trouble. My hearing is so sensitive, that I can hear incandescent light bulbs oscillating. Fluorescents sound like a bees nest. My hearing is so sensitive that my wife says that I can hear her thinking. She's given up on trying to talk under her breath.