I measured the old mat at 4.2mm and the new one at 2.6mm.
Which is a difference of 1.6mm or 1/16th of an inch.
If the arm is 9” then the angular change is 1/(16x9) which is 1/144.
(That is gross 😎)
So it is 1/144 of a radian or ~<1/3 of a degree. I would not worry about 0.4 degrees if you have a stylus that is elliptical.
Maybe a line contact would notice that… but you probably do not have that type of stylus.
Does it sound good?